CLOSINGS: View Closings

Women's center files motion to dismiss lawsuit filed by North Alabama man and his aborted fetus

WAAY 31 has new information on a story we've been following since February. The attorneys for the Alabama Women's Center recently filed a motion to dismiss to a lawsuit filed against them by a North Alabama man and his aborted fetus.

Ryan Magers' story is getting a ton of attention, not just in North Alabama, but nationwide. His attorney said Ryan is turning down interviews with national news media and from here out, he's not doing any more TV interviews at the request of his employer. However, we were able to sit down with his attorney, Brent Helms, on Tuesday to learn more about how they plan to move forward with this case.

Helms said it's been nearly two months since his client, Magers, filed a suit against the Alabama Women's Center for his ex-girlfriend's abortion. The attorneys for Huntsville's only abortion clinic responded by filing a motion to dismiss.

"We anticipated what they would file and were prepared for it, so now we just have to prepare for court," Helms said.

In the motion, the women's center's attorneys argue no laws were broken when Magers' ex-girlfriend aborted the fetus referred to as Baby Roe.

WAAY 31 reached out to the attorneys representing the women's center. Sara Tucker, who's based out of Atlanta, sent us this statement:

"This lawsuit is an assault on equal rights, fundamentally undermining a woman’s autonomy over her own body and the confidentiality of her own medical care. While some fringe groups hope to push healthcare for women, including abortion care, out of reach in Alabama, the law in Alabama and the United States is clear - abortion of a six week embryo is legal, constitutionally protected, and does not give rise to civil liability."

Helms responded to the motion to dismiss by saying it all comes down to whether Baby Roe is a person.

"If Baby Roe is a person and personhood is granted, which in this case it has been, then Baby Roe posses a 14th Amendment right to equal protection under the law," Helms said.

Helms is referring to a Madison County probate judge's decision to allow an estate to be opened for Baby Roe, recognizing the fetus as someone with legal rights. Helms also said there's precedent in Alabama that recognizes an unborn fetus as a person.

He's arguing that if an unborn fetus is considered a person when a pregnant woman's fetus is killed in a car wreck or a pregnant woman is murdered and the fetus is also killed, that fetus should also be viewed as a person in the case of an abortion.

"It's either an unborn child is a person or an unborn child is not a person. What we have is in congruent in the state of Alabama. We say we recognize the personhood of unborn children in certain circumstances, but not all circumstances," Helms said.

The hearing on the motion to dismiss this case is scheduled for July 24th at the Madison County Courthouse. Helms told WAAY 31 that whatever the outcome is, an appeal will likely be filed either way.

Huntsville/Redstone
Clear
56° wxIcon
Hi: 61° Lo: 33°
Feels Like: 56°
Muscle Shoals
Clear
59° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 59°
Huntsville/Madison
Clear
56° wxIcon
Hi: 59° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 56°
Decatur
Clear
56° wxIcon
Hi: 60° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 56°
Fort Payne
Clear
57° wxIcon
Hi: 60° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 57°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 499411

Reported Deaths: 10149
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson719951403
Mobile36396741
Madison32674469
Tuscaloosa24391423
Montgomery22789523
Shelby22250219
Baldwin19915289
Lee15070161
Calhoun13961296
Morgan13785255
Etowah13413327
Marshall11458215
Houston10121264
Elmore9509190
Limestone9435139
St. Clair9050228
Cullman8993183
Lauderdale8628214
DeKalb8507175
Talladega7643165
Walker6600260
Jackson6551104
Autauga634492
Blount6252128
Colbert6007121
Coffee5261104
Dale4680107
Russell407534
Franklin400779
Covington3996107
Chilton3911104
Escambia379473
Tallapoosa3637143
Clarke344553
Chambers3432111
Dallas3428142
Pike292973
Marion288796
Lawrence285787
Winston258568
Bibb246058
Marengo244657
Geneva240270
Pickens225757
Barbour213851
Hale212569
Fayette202657
Butler201466
Henry183541
Cherokee178140
Monroe166739
Randolph165141
Washington157036
Macon147845
Crenshaw146755
Clay146254
Cleburne140141
Lamar133933
Lowndes133151
Wilcox123225
Bullock117736
Conecuh107224
Perry106427
Sumter100832
Coosa90324
Greene88732
Choctaw55723
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 782206

Reported Deaths: 11543
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby878791517
Davidson82125874
Knox46447589
Hamilton40698463
Rutherford38749388
Williamson25489204
Sumner21542320
Montgomery17539213
Out of TN1718496
Wilson16618211
Unassigned15837126
Sullivan14499275
Blount14189184
Bradley13067141
Washington12840234
Maury12273162
Sevier12158165
Putnam10660170
Madison10136232
Robertson9027121
Anderson8103158
Hamblen8088166
Greene7315145
Tipton6974103
Coffee6432115
Dickson6295106
Gibson6200141
Cumberland6137123
Carter5998155
McMinn597193
Roane594696
Bedford5841120
Loudon573666
Jefferson5717119
Lawrence558083
Monroe539591
Warren533377
Hawkins529598
Dyer5248101
Franklin476585
Fayette468773
Obion437195
Lincoln416462
Rhea415573
Cocke403996
Cheatham397944
Marshall392857
Campbell383459
Weakley379960
Giles375897
Henderson362574
Carroll349381
White339866
Hardeman339465
Macon337773
Hardin332063
Lauderdale310042
Henry301675
Marion295945
Wayne288830
Scott288644
Overton286558
Claiborne284769
McNairy268753
Hickman267941
DeKalb267251
Haywood265160
Smith257936
Grainger244846
Trousdale240022
Morgan231138
Fentress230044
Johnson217538
Chester202448
Bledsoe201310
Crockett197447
Unicoi182147
Polk179122
Cannon178630
Union174134
Grundy170230
Lake167926
Sequatchie157527
Humphreys155621
Decatur154237
Benton151339
Lewis147625
Meigs126823
Jackson125734
Stewart124425
Clay107131
Houston103832
Perry103528
Moore94716
Van Buren79720
Pickett74723
Hancock50012

Community Events