STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

WAAY 31 I-TEAM: Judge overrode parole officer’s recommendation for Alabama man now charged with murder

The Alabama judge said it's 'normal' to go against a probation officer's recommendation.

Posted: Oct 10, 2019 5:24 PM
Updated: Oct 10, 2019 6:46 PM

The WAAY 31 I-TEAM is hearing from an Alabama judge who let a man on probation continue to be on the streets. That man is now charged with double murder in Nashville and attempted murder.

Jermaine Agee has a three-page rap sheet in Alabama filled with violent offenses like attempted murder, which he pleaded down. He has charges of robbery and theft from Autagua County, too. Agee was let out of jail and put on probation in 2018 for the robbery and theft charges.

In May, Agee was arrested by Huntsville police for loitering and drug paraphernalia. Court documents say Agee was smoking crack behind a dumpster, and because of those charges, Agee's probation officer asked the courts to issue an arrest warrant for him, because he also failed to report to her in April.

Court documents show Agee's probation officer recommended to Judge Sibley Reynolds that he should go back to the Department of Corrections. The Alabama Board of Pardons and Paroles told WAAY 31 Agee was picked up on August 3rd in Nashville and brought back to Alabama.

Judge Reynolds decided to keep him in jail for one night and continue his probation, according to Alabama Board of Pardons and Paroles officials. Agee was released back to the streets on August 20th. He was also not allowed to leave the state because of his probation.

After calling Judge Reynolds for two days, he got back to the WAAY 31 I-TEAM. We spoke with Reynolds on the phone and asked him why he released Agee.

Judge Reynolds said he could not 'independently recall' the details of the case or why he let him out. He stated he hears about 500 cases like this a year.

We asked Judge Reynolds about Agee's Huntsville charges, which were clear probation violations. He said those charges, in his opinion, were not severe enough to send him to an overcrowded jail or prison. We then asked Reynolds why he went against the probation officer's recommendation. He said that is 'normal' to override a probation officer's recommendation.

Agee was arrested on Monday for brutally stabbing and killing his ex-girlfriend, Mayra Garcia, and her 13-year-old son, Jayden Taylor. According to Nashville police, Agee broke into the family home and went room to room, stabbing the victims. Garcia's 16-year-old daughter was also stabbed, but the 8-year-old in the house escaped.

The children's biological father, Lewis Taylor, spoke with FOX 17 in Nashville. He told the reporter he's a former police officer and now lives in Arizona. When he got the call Monday, he immediately flew to Nashville to be with his surviving children.

"I'm just in shock," said Taylor.

He said his oldest daughter is still trying to recover from her injuries.

"She's got cuts everywhere, trying to walk, trying to do everything normally like she always do, she's hanging in there," said Taylor.

Taylor's family is trying to heal and cope with their losses, mourning a mother and child.

"Somehow she got pulled into that vicious monster," said Taylor.

Family members of Agee's told WAAY 31 they knew he was a danger and said he should have been locked up before the killings happened. Garcia had filed misdemeanor domestic violence charges against Agee last week, but because those were filed in Tennessee instead of Alabama, Agee's probation officer wasn't notified.

Agee now faces two counts of murder and one attempted murder charge in Tennessee.

Huntsville/Redstone
Partly Cloudy
53° wxIcon
Hi: 68° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 53°
Muscle Shoals
Clear
56° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 56°
Huntsville/Madison
Partly Cloudy
52° wxIcon
Hi: 66° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 52°
Decatur
Partly Cloudy
53° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 53°
Fort Payne
Partly Cloudy
55° wxIcon
Hi: 68° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 55°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 521623

Reported Deaths: 10739
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson754061493
Mobile39067799
Madison34040496
Tuscaloosa25367444
Montgomery24019567
Shelby23186239
Baldwin20701302
Lee15589165
Calhoun14342311
Morgan14158271
Etowah13685346
Marshall11995220
Houston10404278
Elmore10011200
Limestone9852147
Cullman9503189
St. Clair9463234
Lauderdale9265228
DeKalb8757181
Talladega8115171
Walker7139275
Jackson6756110
Autauga6750103
Blount6519134
Colbert6229130
Coffee5424113
Dale4772111
Russell430038
Franklin420782
Chilton4101109
Covington4061114
Tallapoosa3907146
Escambia390174
Dallas3525149
Chambers3514122
Clarke347060
Marion3072100
Pike306176
Lawrence295995
Winston273172
Bibb256059
Marengo248361
Geneva246075
Pickens233259
Barbour226455
Hale218575
Butler212967
Fayette209460
Henry188044
Cherokee182644
Randolph177241
Monroe172540
Washington165238
Macon155648
Clay150155
Crenshaw149457
Cleburne146741
Lamar139734
Lowndes136553
Wilcox124427
Bullock121640
Conecuh109428
Perry107626
Sumter103232
Coosa99428
Greene91434
Choctaw58824
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 830484

Reported Deaths: 12049
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby927281585
Davidson87309923
Knox49411623
Hamilton43254481
Rutherford41816420
Williamson27237214
Sumner23155339
Montgomery19075224
Wilson17979224
Out of TN1794598
Unassigned16655134
Sullivan16096287
Blount14963194
Bradley14518147
Washington14129242
Sevier13116174
Maury13021168
Putnam11155173
Madison10771240
Robertson9567127
Anderson8599171
Hamblen8478170
Greene7715152
Tipton7216102
Coffee6824121
Dickson6724109
Cumberland6555127
Carter6443156
Bedford6409127
Gibson6387144
McMinn634295
Roane6174102
Jefferson6061121
Loudon601169
Lawrence578686
Hawkins5766106
Monroe570295
Warren550881
Dyer5357104
Franklin508388
Fayette490377
Obion449996
Cocke442998
Cheatham442254
Rhea430375
Lincoln429563
Marshall410358
Campbell408462
Weakley401962
Giles393998
Henderson372475
Macon357376
Carroll357182
White353968
Hardin349166
Hardeman345863
Lauderdale314244
Henry311875
Marion308346
Claiborne305573
Scott305145
Overton296360
Wayne294234
Hickman279645
McNairy276754
DeKalb274953
Smith273938
Haywood268161
Grainger258449
Trousdale248722
Morgan245539
Fentress238046
Johnson230238
Bledsoe209411
Chester209351
Crockett200948
Polk199024
Unicoi194149
Cannon188831
Union185634
Grundy177232
Humphreys173621
Lake169526
Sequatchie166428
Benton162940
Decatur157338
Lewis155726
Meigs134123
Stewart130028
Jackson129635
Clay109031
Houston108333
Perry105728
Moore99717
Van Buren83421
Pickett75624
Hancock54712

Community Events