WAAY 31 I-TEAM: Madison Co. judge refuses to send killer to prison despite probation violation

Martin Wayne Hicks Jr. was found guilty of multiple charges in Marshall County in August. This week, a judge sentenced him to 45 days of work release for violating his probation.

Posted: Dec 5, 2019 7:31 PM
Updated: Dec 5, 2019 8:39 PM

Two families are looking for answers after Martin Wayne Hicks Jr. violated his probation but was not sent to a state prison to serve his 10 year prison sentence.

This week, a judge sentenced him to 45 days of work release.

It's a story the WAAY 31 I-Team spent the past year following. (Tap here and here to read more)

Hicks was found guilty of negligent homicide after he ran over his girlfriend, killing her, in 2016 while under the influence of meth. He was given a suspended sentence as long as he followed the terms of his probation.

The Madison County District Attorney's office told WAAY 31 in December 2018 that Hicks should be sent to prison for violating his probation terms. However, Prosecutors said the the judge decided he shouldn't be sent to prison and there is nothing they can do about it.

Terry Steelman said he's confused as to why his niece, Jamie Varvel's, killer is not headed to state prison after hurting another woman and her child last year.

“It’s pretty much a smack in the face for all of us," Steelman said.

He said he was promised by the District Attorney's office Hicks was headed to prison.

"We want to know why there was any decision that needed to be made. He broke his probation and there should no be decision in that he should go to jail for the original sentence. Period," he said.

Hicks was found guilty in Marshall County in August on three charges after he assaulted his now ex-girlfriend and her child last December.

The judge on the case gave him 2 years of unsupervised probation, and a suspended jail sentence.

"There seems to be a disconnect between crime and punishment, and I’m not sure why that is," Steelman said.

Wednesday, Hicks had a probation revocation hearing at the Madison County Courthouse.

The judge on the case, James Smith, sentenced him to 45 days of work release.

"If they slap him on the wrist, then what’s to stop him from doing that again?," he said.

Hicks now ex-girlfriend said she testified at Wednesday’s hearing, but claims the judge didn’t believe the charges were serious enough to send Hicks to prison.

“Why would a victim put herself through that when a judge is allowed to let him go?" he said.

Steelman thinks the latest hearing points out flaws in the legal system.

“I just thought it was ridiculous. I just wanted to be in a room with the judge with the DA and say why? Why is that allowable?," he said.

WAAY 31 called and tried to speak with Judge Smith and was told he was out sick.

His assistant told us he doesn't talk to the media and he will be in trial all next week.

Huntsville/Redstone
Cloudy
44° wxIcon
Hi: 52° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 42°
Muscle Shoals
Cloudy
48° wxIcon
Hi: 55° Lo: 33°
Feels Like: 45°
Huntsville/Madison
Cloudy
47° wxIcon
Hi: 53° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 44°
Decatur
Cloudy
42° wxIcon
Hi: 52° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 38°
Fort Payne
Cloudy
31° wxIcon
Hi: 54° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 31°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 424028

Reported Deaths: 6121
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson62258921
Mobile30381549
Madison27160186
Tuscaloosa20779267
Montgomery19049305
Shelby18572114
Baldwin16346182
Lee12515101
Morgan12260113
Etowah11757168
Calhoun11161200
Marshall10199107
Houston8630148
Cullman8036105
Limestone802874
Elmore7849101
DeKalb768897
Lauderdale760083
St. Clair7555120
Talladega6180108
Walker5903174
Jackson581341
Colbert533573
Blount530883
Autauga519855
Coffee443956
Dale398581
Franklin367548
Chilton337665
Russell331710
Covington327768
Escambia319342
Dallas303396
Chambers284269
Clarke282133
Tallapoosa2617107
Pike249429
Marion246250
Lawrence244247
Winston227335
Bibb216247
Geneva202535
Marengo199729
Pickens197031
Hale176442
Barbour173036
Butler170258
Fayette169026
Cherokee160530
Henry154421
Monroe145617
Randolph140735
Washington137726
Clay126745
Crenshaw119544
Lamar118219
Cleburne117723
Macon115035
Lowndes110735
Wilcox103121
Bullock99128
Perry97719
Conecuh94420
Sumter89126
Greene76123
Coosa60515
Choctaw51524
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 687751

Reported Deaths: 8430
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby765191128
Davidson70950665
Knox38829400
Hamilton34687327
Rutherford33228285
Unassigned22839126
Williamson21449140
Sumner18262232
Out of TN1618380
Montgomery14450149
Wilson14449157
Sullivan12606211
Blount11914125
Washington11911191
Maury10962123
Bradley1079191
Sevier10495108
Putnam9952136
Madison9131179
Robertson764585
Hamblen6990109
Anderson6792103
Greene6598108
Tipton621065
Gibson5639111
Coffee562882
Cumberland540072
Dickson536378
Bedford532589
Roane521279
Carter5109112
Lawrence508969
McMinn508573
Warren498753
Loudon495550
Jefferson477975
Dyer474982
Monroe457162
Hawkins446268
Franklin412161
Obion399679
Fayette397851
Rhea382456
Lincoln379444
Marshall345436
Cocke343856
Weakley339948
Cheatham336230
Henderson333057
Campbell324540
Giles321772
White311343
Carroll310459
Hardeman309452
Hardin298147
Lauderdale293731
Macon288850
Wayne261319
Henry260858
Overton253843
DeKalb242341
Haywood239845
McNairy238642
Smith231327
Trousdale228814
Marion228431
Scott225431
Hickman223534
Fentress212831
Claiborne212729
Grainger209035
Johnson201832
Morgan189015
Crockett180738
Bledsoe174210
Chester173837
Unicoi167043
Cannon157719
Lake155519
Decatur147326
Polk143617
Union139422
Grundy139321
Sequatchie137118
Humphreys132817
Benton132135
Lewis127520
Meigs114416
Stewart105520
Jackson104021
Perry94725
Clay93926
Houston93922
Moore8009
Pickett67919
Van Buren6607
Hancock4056

Community Events