BREAKING NEWS Alabama adds 1,655 new coronavirus cases; total at 99,390 Full Story
SEVERE WX : Heat Advisory View Alerts

WAAY 31 I-TEAM: Investigation still open months after deadly crash involving Madison police officer

The officer's name has not yet been released.

Posted: Sep 30, 2019 5:41 PM
Updated: Sep 30, 2019 7:51 PM

The WAAY 31 I-TEAM has learned more about a deadly crash investigators say was caused by an off-duty Madison police officer.

More than three months after the crash killed 92-year-old Phyllis Pine, we know one investigation is still ongoing and every other hasn't even started.

The WAAY 31 I-TEAM discovered the officer is still at home recovering from his injuries. 

The initial crash report shows the Madison police officer, whose name has not yet been released, was trying to avoid rear-ending two cars that were either stopped or moving slowly on Wall Triana Highway. We learned the officer swerved into oncoming traffic and hit a car head-on.

We took the community's questions to investigators to find out if and when charges could be filed. 

Some family members and friends of 92-year-old Phyllis Pine are growing restless, three months after her death and a report blaming the crash on an off-duty Madison police officer. Huntsville police told the WAAY 31 I-TEAM that investigators need more time.

Investigators say they're waiting on reports from the Department of Forensic Science, a department the state repeatedly cited for lengthy delays and back-ups. It means the case is still weeks away from reaching the Madison County District Attorney's Office.

Assistant District Attorney Shauna Barnett vowed the officer won't be getting special treatment.

"We're going to handle it just like every other case, that it didn't involve a police officer, just like we normally would," Barnett said.

Madison Police Chief Dave Jernigan wouldn't go on camera but said his department's internal investigation into the crash won't start until the officer whose name nobody will give out is back on duty. Just like the D.A.'s office, he's also waiting on a final report from Huntsville police.

Even though the initial crash report blames the off-duty officer, we're still working to learn if he was speeding or using a cell phone when the wreck happened.

Barnett handles the majority of the traffic homicide cases and said not all crashes involving a death are criminal.

"The Traffic Homicide Unit is investigating. They are doing it like they would any other investigation, which is to be thorough investigation, getting all the data they can," Barnett said. "We have a whole civil side of the justice system. That's what deals with the money damages and the loss of life, a loss of income, all that type of thing. Some of those don't meet the threshold for criminal charges."

Barnett explained they take circumstances surrounding the crash into consideration when deciding if a driver should face criminal charges.

"Ninety-nine point nine percent of wrecks of any kind are caused by operator error on somebody's part. Somebody's following too close. Somebody is not yielding the right of way. Somebody is speeding, and there is a difference in speeding 5, 10, 15 mph, and 50 miles an hour over or some egregious speed," Barnett said.

Prosecutors won't get the case until they know that information. We checked court records and at this time, no civil lawsuit has been filed by Pine's family against either the City of Madison or the Madison Police Department after the wreck. 

The Madison County Commission is working with the Alabama Department of Transportation on improvements along the road in the area

Plans include widening the shoulder and adding a dedicated turn lane for southbound drivers who want to turn left onto McCrary Road. The commission said a start date on the project has not yet been determined.

Huntsville
Few Clouds
88° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 72°
Feels Like: 96°
Florence
Clear
92° wxIcon
Hi: 95° Lo: 74°
Feels Like: 99°
Fayetteville
Few Clouds
88° wxIcon
Hi: 92° Lo: 72°
Feels Like: 94°
Decatur
Clear
89° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 98°
Scottsboro
Clear
82° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 72°
Feels Like: 94°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 99390

Reported Deaths: 1733
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson13109243
Mobile9947207
Montgomery6835148
Madison537834
Tuscaloosa421373
Unassigned359961
Baldwin354425
Shelby328335
Marshall316736
Lee267845
Morgan239318
Etowah212131
DeKalb181913
Calhoun178414
Elmore172338
Walker152664
Houston139812
Russell13682
St. Clair133817
Limestone133313
Dallas132323
Franklin127420
Cullman122512
Colbert118113
Autauga116921
Lauderdale116719
Escambia108217
Talladega102614
Jackson9894
Tallapoosa85579
Chambers84138
Dale83424
Blount8004
Chilton7926
Butler76436
Coffee7616
Covington73520
Pike7097
Clarke6629
Barbour5755
Marion57424
Lowndes57224
Marengo55215
Hale47626
Bullock46411
Winston45311
Perry4424
Bibb4385
Wilcox42910
Monroe4214
Randolph40110
Pickens4009
Conecuh39310
Washington39112
Sumter36018
Lawrence3491
Macon33514
Crenshaw3185
Choctaw28312
Cherokee2737
Henry2633
Geneva2611
Clay2585
Greene25111
Lamar2222
Fayette2075
Cleburne1271
Coosa1012
Out of AL00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 122712

Reported Deaths: 1223
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby23238304
Davidson20620213
Rutherford655354
Hamilton613253
Knox460039
Williamson355125
Sumner343373
Unassigned316110
Out of TN292414
Wilson229023
Bradley194312
Montgomery193913
Sevier18867
Putnam176718
Trousdale15836
Robertson155819
Hamblen139614
Blount130311
Maury12577
Washington12522
Tipton120810
Madison110217
Sullivan99414
Bedford92811
Hardeman91717
Macon86013
Lake7870
Loudon7423
Gibson7175
Bledsoe7051
Fayette6988
Dickson6912
Anderson6846
Dyer6508
Cheatham5957
Henderson5932
Jefferson5684
Obion5654
Lawrence5626
McMinn54720
Coffee5453
Rhea5362
Warren5304
Carter5226
Lauderdale5088
Haywood5006
Greene4928
Cocke4752
Roane4752
Hawkins4727
Hardin4718
Cumberland4576
Smith4524
Weakley4514
Monroe4449
Giles38113
McNairy3785
DeKalb3602
Franklin3304
Carroll3143
Lincoln3021
Marshall3013
White2935
Henry2880
Johnson2800
Claiborne2720
Crockett2695
Hickman2680
Campbell2481
Wayne2262
Marion2244
Chester2212
Decatur2133
Polk2063
Grainger1970
Overton1951
Unicoi1660
Union1600
Benton1551
Cannon1470
Jackson1271
Humphreys1243
Morgan1221
Scott1190
Grundy1142
Meigs1060
Sequatchie1050
Fentress930
Perry810
Hancock802
Clay760
Lewis751
Stewart740
Moore630
Houston590
Van Buren360
Pickett351

Community Events