STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

User funded probation companies face lawsuit in Giles County

Private probation companies are facing lawsuits in Tennessee for extorting money from the people they supervise.

Posted: Apr 27, 2018 9:31 PM
Updated: Apr 28, 2018 5:10 PM

Two private, for profit probation companies are involved in a federal lawsuit in Giles County for extorting money from the people they supervise.

According to the press release sent by the Civil Rights Corps, PSI Probation and Community Probation Services are contracted with Giles County to run a "user funded" probation system.

The companies claim that the only source of income they receive is from the fees that the people they supervise pay them.

This lawsuit is similar to the one filed in 2015 that shut down the use of private probation companies in Rutherford County, TN.

Karen McNeil is one of the five people now suing Giles County and the two private probation companies it uses. She claims that she was repeatedly jailed for being too poor to pay her supervision fees.

“Misdemeanor probation should not be run at the expense of the poor and as revenue streams for the
county and private companies,” said Civil Rights Corps Attorney Jonas Wang. “The private companies are
essentially debt collectors for the county. This ‘user-funded’ scheme creates a creature previously
unknown to American law: a probation officer with an inherent conflict of interest because the company
relies on the same people it supervises to turn a profit.”

The lawsuit states that McNeil pled guilty to driving on a suspended license in 2015.
She was then put on probation and ordered to pay $426 in fines and fees - plus $45 a month to the probation company that supervised her and $45 for each drug test.

McNeil said she paid more than double her initial fine, but when she missed a probation appearance because she was in the hospital, her probation office filed a violation of probation and she ended up in jail.

According to the lawsuit, McNeil has been sent to jail on four different occasions in the past three years.

Since then she has been paying her fees out of her disability benefits and hasn't been able to afford rent or utilities, so she lives in a tent.

“This is our two-tiered justice system at its finest – rich people can buy their way off probation, while poor
people charged with petty offenses get squeezed for every penny,” said Attorney Kyle Mothershead in the release.
“Probation is not supposed to keep people down.”

The federal lawsuit is from Civil Rights Corps, Hughes Socol Piers Resnick & Dym and Attorney Kyle Mothershead.

In the lawsuit that took place in Rutherford County, Civil Rights Corps secured a $14 million settlement against the county and its private probation company, Providence Community Corrections.

As part of that lawsuit a federal judge ordered Rutherford County to release several inmates from its jail and the county ended its use of for-profit probation.

Huntsville
Clear
60° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 60°
Florence
Clear
61° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 61°
Fayetteville
Clear
63° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 58°
Feels Like: 63°
Decatur
Clear
60° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 58°
Feels Like: 60°
Scottsboro
Overcast
55° wxIcon
Hi: 80° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 55°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 152272

Reported Deaths: 2621
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson22400372
Mobile14282314
Tuscaloosa9983132
Montgomery9691196
Madison899992
Shelby703560
Lee643966
Baldwin637567
Marshall426748
Calhoun410259
Etowah402049
Morgan394532
Houston363132
DeKalb316727
Elmore309552
St. Clair279742
Limestone269227
Walker268092
Talladega255034
Cullman225823
Lauderdale206340
Autauga199928
Franklin199131
Jackson199114
Colbert190627
Russell19023
Dallas185227
Blount183823
Chilton180531
Escambia170928
Covington164729
Coffee16409
Dale162551
Pike130212
Chambers127343
Tallapoosa127286
Clarke126716
Marion104229
Butler99840
Barbour9819
Marengo96721
Winston89913
Geneva8337
Pickens80317
Randolph79514
Lawrence79230
Bibb78913
Hale74529
Cherokee71514
Clay70712
Lowndes69927
Bullock63517
Henry6316
Monroe6279
Washington62112
Crenshaw59030
Perry5796
Wilcox55712
Conecuh55413
Fayette54712
Macon52919
Cleburne5247
Sumter46421
Lamar4575
Choctaw38612
Greene33316
Coosa1963
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 232061

Reported Deaths: 2922
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby34370552
Davidson29801325
Knox1183387
Hamilton11097102
Rutherford11031106
Williamson661848
Sumner5636107
Wilson440253
Putnam411053
Montgomery385751
Out of TN379435
Unassigned37653
Madison361378
Bradley340821
Sullivan318844
Sevier314920
Blount310231
Washington308043
Maury307435
Robertson248539
Hamblen232743
Tipton219222
Gibson205437
Dyer202326
Hardeman178732
Coffee176020
Trousdale17407
Obion163617
Bedford159020
Dickson156218
Wayne15607
Greene155650
Anderson155513
Loudon154010
Fayette152022
McMinn150832
Cumberland148924
Lawrence146217
Jefferson145818
Weakley143425
Carter141532
Henderson135425
Monroe134823
Warren13399
Hardin131319
Lauderdale130818
Macon125724
Franklin121115
Haywood119025
Roane11857
Overton111211
Johnson11046
Hawkins109923
Carroll109324
McNairy108825
White107614
Marshall10528
Rhea104816
Cheatham96911
Lake9683
Smith93313
Bledsoe9244
Cocke92212
Giles89234
Campbell8647
Fentress8497
Lincoln8012
Crockett76620
Henry74110
Hickman73913
Chester71214
Marion6999
DeKalb67216
Decatur62511
Grainger5314
Grundy5168
Claiborne4956
Union4932
Polk46913
Jackson4165
Humphreys4094
Morgan4086
Houston38914
Benton3879
Cannon3862
Unicoi3641
Clay36312
Lewis3502
Sequatchie3294
Scott3244
Stewart3087
Meigs2944
Moore2452
Pickett2445
Perry2041
Van Buren1911
Hancock1123

Community Events