SEVERE WX : Heat Advisory View Alerts

Cousin of victim in Morgan County shooting remembers her smile and laugh as she mourns

Emily Payne, 21, was one of seven people who were shot and killed late Thursday night in the Valhermoso Springs community.

Posted: Jun 5, 2020 10:54 PM
Updated: Jun 8, 2020 9:22 AM

Whitney McPeters was spending the week in Panama City, Florida, with some of her family. She was on the last day of her vacation on Friday when she received a horrible phone call. 

"It's like your whole body goes weak. I remember my legs just suddenly felt like jello," McPeters said. 

Emily Brooke Payne, 21, was one of seven people who were shot and killed late Thursday night in Valhermoso Springs in Morgan County. (Courtesy: Whitney McPeters) Emily Brooke Payne, 21, was one of seven people who were shot and killed late Thursday night in Valhermoso Springs in Morgan County. (Courtesy: Whitney McPeters)

The call was to inform her and her family that her cousin, Emily Brooke Payne, was one of seven people who was shot and killed Thursday night. Payne had just celebrated her 21st birthday on Tuesday.

"To be the kind of person who could go into a house and look seven people in the face and do what whoever or multiple whoevers did to these people, what kind of person could you be?" McPeters said.

She remembered her cousin as being a bright and kind person with whom McPeters spent much of her childhood.

"She was a very bubbly girl. She was always smiling, she was always happy and joking around and cutting up with everyone," McPeters said.

McPeters described Payne as someone who was also very trusting of people. She wondered if that trust may have led her into what happened Thursday night.

"As young as she was and so trusting of everybody, I guess she just didn't really realize that something like this could be a possibility, you know? She trusted everyone she came into contact with. She was good to everybody. She loved everybody. I don't think I really know anyone personally that has anything bad to say about her," said McPeters.

That was part of what made the news so difficult. Many of those who were killed Thursday night had lives that overlapped with one another. McPeters said she, Emily and some other family members spent summers together with the children of another one of the victims, Tammy England Muzzey, 45.

McPeters said Muzzey owned the house where the shooting took place.

"We all went to school together," McPeters said. "Emily and Tammy's daughters, they were some of each other's best friends growing up and even into adulthood. They all stayed very close."

Shortly before 11 p.m. Friday night, a GoFundMe account to help with funeral expenses for Payne reached nearly $1,400. 

McPeters said the support comes from the closeness of the community, adding that the impact of losing those seven lives reverberates to everyone in Valhermoso Springs.

"Every other house here, someone's more than likely related, about every other house down this street. I mean, that's how tiny of a town it is. There are no strangers. We've all known each other our entire lives. We've all grown up together. Some of the elders in the town here have watched us grow up and now is watching our children grow up," McPeters said.

The FBI and the Morgan County Sheriff's Office continued to work the investigation late into Friday night. So far, they have not released much information about who they may suspect is behind the shooting, but said that person or persons may be out of town or state at this point. 

McPeters said she can't imagine anyone in their community harming so many people in such a horrific way.

"That's why it's so hard to imagine that it's happened, because I can't think of anyone around here that would want to hurt so many people in our town like that," said McPeters.

If you would like to donate to the GoFundMe for Emily Payne, click here.

Huntsville
Few Clouds
79° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 73°
Feels Like: 82°
Florence
Clear
81° wxIcon
Hi: 96° Lo: 75°
Feels Like: 85°
Fayetteville
Clear
79° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 74°
Feels Like: 79°
Decatur
Clear
79° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 73°
Feels Like: 82°
Scottsboro
Clear
79° wxIcon
Hi: 94° Lo: 73°
Feels Like: 83°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 58225

Reported Deaths: 1183
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson7449176
Mobile5349157
Montgomery4732118
Madison290112
Tuscaloosa283754
Marshall213313
Shelby188027
Lee179337
Baldwin149912
Morgan14897
DeKalb11457
Etowah113614
Walker113537
Elmore111825
Dallas103312
Franklin97016
Unassigned84228
Russell7610
Autauga74318
Limestone7254
Cullman7136
Chambers69932
Houston6848
St. Clair6714
Lauderdale6647
Tallapoosa66272
Butler65931
Calhoun6426
Colbert6138
Escambia56212
Jackson5113
Pike5016
Lowndes49723
Coffee4734
Covington45214
Talladega4517
Dale4283
Barbour4263
Bullock38110
Marengo38111
Hale37523
Chilton3693
Blount3671
Marion35514
Clarke3396
Wilcox3328
Winston3167
Sumter30613
Randolph28610
Monroe2833
Pickens2827
Perry2702
Conecuh2558
Bibb2382
Macon2359
Choctaw22112
Greene2029
Washington1679
Henry1653
Lawrence1590
Crenshaw1433
Cherokee1407
Geneva1100
Lamar961
Clay942
Fayette923
Coosa681
Cleburne621
Out of AL00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 69061

Reported Deaths: 783
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby14891233
Davidson14550157
Rutherford394439
Hamilton372139
Sumner218957
Williamson211918
Knox191515
Out of TN177510
Trousdale15165
Wilson133818
Putnam11087
Bradley10966
Unassigned10551
Robertson101013
Sevier9784
Montgomery9067
Tipton7407
Lake6980
Macon6707
Bedford64610
Bledsoe6341
Hamblen5515
Maury5293
Hardeman4804
Madison4092
Fayette4046
Blount3813
Rhea3620
Loudon3532
Dyer3263
Washington3210
McMinn31319
Cheatham3113
Dickson3080
Sullivan2905
Lawrence2626
Cumberland2415
Gibson2371
Anderson2362
Jefferson2191
Lauderdale2184
Smith2022
Warren1831
Cocke1750
Greene1732
Coffee1620
Monroe1626
Haywood1553
Hardin1547
Obion1443
Giles1431
Marshall1412
McNairy1381
Wayne1300
Carter1282
Franklin1273
DeKalb1190
Hickman1180
White1163
Henderson1140
Lincoln1110
Marion1044
Hawkins1032
Roane1000
Chester910
Weakley871
Claiborne860
Overton861
Campbell771
Crockett753
Grundy682
Cannon650
Grainger650
Carroll631
Jackson620
Polk610
Unicoi610
Henry570
Sequatchie540
Humphreys532
Johnson480
Perry450
Decatur440
Meigs400
Morgan371
Fentress350
Stewart340
Scott310
Union310
Clay280
Moore260
Houston250
Benton241
Hancock150
Van Buren140
Lewis130
Pickett80

 

 

Community Events