Huntsville attorney explains what's next in police officer's murder case

Darby's trial is currently scheduled to start Monday.

Posted: Apr 4, 2019 6:44 PM
Updated: Apr 4, 2019 6:48 PM

A Huntsville police officer charged with murder is likely headed for trial.

A judge denied immunity for Officer William Darby after listening to five hours of testimony on Wednesday. Officer Darby testified he shot a suicidal man inside his home last year, because he thought he and his fellow officers were in danger.

Huntsville police and the prosecutors are not allowed to talk about the case because of a gag order issued by the judge.

A defense attorney who's familiar with immunity hearings explained what can be expected in the coming days. Huntsville Attorney Bruce Gardner said he's not surprised to hear Judge Donna Pate already made her decision for Officer William Darby's immunity hearing.

"I have never successfully got one granted, but I know several people in Huntsville have," he said.

Gardner said Darby's attorney didn't convince the judge greater than 50% that Darby acted in self defense when he shot and killed Jeffery Parker on April 3, 2018.

"I'm sure she studied it and was prepared to rule," he said.

WAAY 31 asked Gardner what he thinks will happen next in the case.

"In the case, the officer has the right to seek appellate relief in the form of what's called mandamus," he said.

Simply put, Darby can appeal. Gardner said he expects for Darby's attorney to ask for the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals in Montgomery to review the case in the coming days.

"I think it would be a very quick review of the record and what transpired yesterday," he said.

The court would then decide if the judge should have granted Darby immunity.

"A final ruling that he should have had immunity ends the case," he said.

Gardner said if Darby's case makes it to court, he is still allowed to claim he acted in self defense.

"He's still entitled at his trial to proceed every avenue of self defense, and while on his quest for immunity, he bears the burden of proof. At his trial, the self defense issue will have to be negated by the state," he said.

Darby's trial is currently scheduled to start Monday. Gardner said he expects for the judge to delay the trial if the immunity hearing is reviewed by the appeal court in Montgomery.

Huntsville
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 73°
Florence
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 97° Lo: 73°
Feels Like: 73°
Fayetteville
Clear
70° wxIcon
Hi: 92° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 70°
Decatur
Clear
70° wxIcon
Hi: 94° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 70°
Scottsboro
Broken Clouds
70° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 70°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 94827

Reported Deaths: 1674
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson12743242
Mobile9565206
Montgomery6521148
Madison525030
Tuscaloosa410371
Unassigned347461
Baldwin344323
Shelby320133
Marshall309034
Lee262844
Morgan233017
Etowah207530
DeKalb177113
Calhoun170413
Elmore169438
Walker150264
Houston136412
Russell13422
Dallas131123
St. Clair131016
Limestone128413
Franklin125820
Cullman120112
Colbert115613
Lauderdale113917
Autauga106521
Escambia105416
Talladega98613
Jackson9454
Tallapoosa84979
Chambers83538
Dale82323
Blount7743
Chilton7676
Butler75935
Coffee7475
Covington72620
Pike6907
Barbour5695
Lowndes56724
Marion56724
Marengo54614
Clarke4969
Hale46726
Bullock45411
Winston44411
Perry4364
Wilcox41810
Bibb4164
Monroe4154
Randolph39410
Pickens3849
Conecuh38210
Sumter36218
Lawrence3441
Macon33213
Washington32712
Crenshaw3133
Choctaw27912
Cherokee2637
Geneva2550
Henry2523
Greene25011
Clay2495
Lamar2172
Fayette1985
Cleburne1251
Coosa1012
Out of AL00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 118782

Reported Deaths: 1206
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby22635302
Davidson20185212
Rutherford640453
Hamilton597052
Knox440737
Williamson344825
Sumner336573
Unassigned30809
Out of TN284216
Wilson222923
Montgomery188313
Bradley187412
Sevier18307
Putnam171717
Trousdale15826
Robertson152119
Hamblen137214
Blount124310
Washington12002
Tipton11839
Maury11787
Madison102417
Sullivan93312
Bedford90811
Hardeman87517
Macon85613
Lake7820
Loudon7183
Bledsoe6901
Fayette6708
Gibson6705
Anderson6686
Dickson6662
Dyer6197
Cheatham5737
Jefferson5523
Henderson5472
Lawrence5346
McMinn52420
Rhea5221
Obion5194
Coffee5073
Warren4984
Carter4976
Lauderdale4878
Haywood4576
Hardin4538
Cocke4502
Greene4477
Smith4464
Hawkins4357
Roane4332
Cumberland4126
Monroe4079
Weakley3974
Giles36913
McNairy3665
DeKalb3392
Franklin3134
Carroll2903
Marshall2833
Lincoln2761
White2735
Henry2660
Crockett2604
Johnson2580
Claiborne2550
Hickman2530
Campbell2391
Wayne2252
Marion2164
Chester2112
Decatur1983
Polk1953
Grainger1940
Overton1751
Unicoi1560
Union1500
Cannon1420
Benton1391
Humphreys1203
Jackson1181
Scott1180
Grundy1112
Morgan1031
Sequatchie1020
Meigs1010
Fentress880
Hancock781
Perry770
Clay740
Stewart730
Lewis711
Moore600
Houston570
Van Buren350
Pickett311

Community Events