STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

WAAY 31 I-Team: Crime perception, reality differ for Huntsville police, victims

Huntsville had its largest number of homicides ever in 2018, with 28 homicides.

Posted: Mar 20, 2019 6:21 PM
Updated: Mar 20, 2019 8:03 PM

The WAAY 31 I-Team is examining perception versus reality when it comes to crime in Huntsville. We asked people in Huntsville if they think violent crime in the past 5 years has increased or decreased.

Here are their answers:

"Probably up."
"I really have no idea."
"I'd probably say up."
"Gone up."
"Up."
"I think it's went up."
"It's been about the same."

Those answers - which are both right and wrong - frustrate Huntsville police, who say they're proactively fighting crime and point to drops in the most violent crimes.

Huntsville police shared with us the number of homicides in Huntsville dating back to 2013. Last year was a record year with 28 homicides being the highest in the city's history.

"You don't think it's going to happen to you, and I lived in South Huntsville. Like, it doesn't matter anymore. It doesn't matter if you're from the wealthiest of families, or if you're struggling, or what community you are in," said Tammy Thornton.

Thornton said she didn't know anything about crime in Huntsville until 14 months ago, when her 17-year-old nephew, Brandon Thornton, was killed.

"It was on my patio, so it actually, literally hit home," she said.

The reality of his death changed both her life and her perception of crime in Huntsville. Now, time stands still just like a clock in her home that marks the minute Brandon died.

Thornton has a question for police in Huntsville, after her nephew became another crime stat in last year's highest-ever homicide rate.

"What are we doing to stop all this crime?" she asked.

WAAY 31 went to the commander of the Huntsville Police Department's Criminal Investigation Division, Capt. Mike Izzo, for an answer.

"To just come up with a formula on how to prevent a homicide, that would be like, to be brutally honest, like solving cancer. I don't think it's ever been done, but if it has, we would love that formula," he said.

Izzo joined the Huntsville Police Department more than 25 years ago, and said although people might think the city's becoming more dangerous, perception isn't always reality.

He gave stats that cover the last six years. Aggravated assaults are slightly up from 2013, but they were significantly down last year. The city also had a dip in robberies. Huntsville police said they think they might know why.

          

"We're constantly coming up with different ways and how to address. It's just problem solving. Do we sit around? Yes, we get the numbers and we look at the numbers. Then, we look and see, are there specific areas that might be a hot spot?" Izzo said.

It's not enough for Thornton, who thinks about her nephew's death every day.

"Brandon is gone. He's forgotten by some. He's remembered by some, but he's going to be a number, but before, like I said, I wasn't involved, because it didn't hit home," Thornton said.

It always hits home for Izzo.

"I can tell you right now that, and this is from my heart, nobody is just a number to us. Every crime, especially every violent crime, has a victim and has a family that's attached to that crime," he said.

The suspect in the murder of Thornton's nephew is out of jail on bond, and the case still has to be presented to a Madison County Grand Jury.

"The next time I see Brandon is when I go to heaven. That's it," Thornton said.

Huntsville/Madison
Cloudy
43° wxIcon
Hi: 56° Lo: 44°
Feels Like: 40°
Muscle Shoals
Partly Cloudy
45° wxIcon
Hi: 51° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 40°
Huntsville/Madison
Mostly Cloudy
43° wxIcon
Hi: 51° Lo: 41°
Feels Like: 40°
Decatur
Cloudy
44° wxIcon
Hi: 53° Lo: 45°
Feels Like: 39°
Fort Payne
Cloudy
50° wxIcon
Hi: 58° Lo: 48°
Feels Like: 50°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 445909

Reported Deaths: 6896
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson651891049
Mobile32138590
Madison28596223
Tuscaloosa21703276
Montgomery20220336
Shelby19584138
Baldwin17496216
Lee13378109
Morgan12741145
Etowah12196189
Calhoun11626228
Marshall10513126
Houston9097168
Limestone842481
Cullman8363125
Elmore8283112
Lauderdale7986112
DeKalb7935112
St. Clair7915139
Talladega6552112
Walker6068184
Jackson605649
Colbert560194
Blount551794
Autauga544065
Coffee470569
Dale415186
Franklin378150
Russell362816
Chilton348079
Covington344681
Escambia342244
Tallapoosa3184109
Dallas314197
Chambers308575
Clarke307339
Pike267735
Lawrence256958
Marion255763
Winston235243
Bibb224751
Geneva214747
Marengo212031
Pickens201831
Barbour188240
Hale187444
Fayette181230
Butler175960
Cherokee167433
Henry161325
Monroe153521
Randolph148236
Washington144027
Clay131050
Crenshaw126245
Macon124337
Cleburne123627
Lamar121324
Lowndes117636
Wilcox109422
Bullock105829
Perry100518
Conecuh98222
Sumter90828
Greene78323
Coosa64619
Choctaw52224
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 712406

Reported Deaths: 9162
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby792151211
Davidson73395716
Knox40479455
Hamilton36114353
Rutherford34354299
Unassigned23968147
Williamson22359154
Sumner18891245
Out of TN1653784
Montgomery15282156
Wilson14907170
Sullivan13036229
Blount12443136
Washington12236209
Maury11346133
Bradley11329104
Sevier10910128
Putnam10222153
Madison9387188
Robertson795288
Hamblen7286128
Anderson7054116
Greene6790120
Tipton640975
Coffee579088
Gibson5777118
Dickson560285
Cumberland557079
Bedford547895
Roane537585
McMinn526874
Lawrence525870
Carter5229124
Loudon512755
Warren511659
Jefferson499478
Dyer488587
Monroe472865
Hawkins462477
Franklin427768
Fayette416753
Obion407686
Rhea392858
Lincoln388549
Cocke360666
Marshall358541
Cheatham351232
Weakley347350
Campbell339842
Henderson339262
Giles335776
Carroll319062
White318350
Hardeman316755
Hardin307551
Lauderdale300635
Macon296354
Henry270761
Wayne270425
Overton260646
McNairy250144
DeKalb248545
Haywood245651
Marion237034
Smith235830
Claiborne231834
Trousdale231017
Scott230932
Hickman230337
Grainger218241
Fentress218036
Johnson205835
Morgan197417
Crockett184139
Chester179539
Bledsoe178811
Unicoi170347
Cannon162223
Lake158522
Polk151417
Decatur149028
Union146525
Grundy144222
Sequatchie143020
Humphreys138117
Benton134435
Lewis131321
Meigs119817
Stewart112621
Jackson107024
Clay96926
Perry96725
Houston95126
Moore8359
Pickett69221
Van Buren6769
Hancock4267

Community Events