Bench trial to begin for owner of allegedly abused elephant

"Nosey," the African elephant, was seized by Lawrence County officials in early November and is currently in the care of The Elephant Sanctuary in Tennessee.

Posted: Dec 15, 2017 8:02 AM
Updated: Dec 15, 2017 9:16 AM

The future of an allegedly abused elephant may be decided by the end of Friday.


Hugo Liebel, the owner of "Nosey," the African elephant is set to appear for a bench trial at the Lawrence County Courthouse Friday morning.

On November 7, Lawrence County Animal Control Officer Kimberly Carpenter said she received "numerous complaints concerning an elephant and four miniature horses," according to her affidavit.

The original complaint said the animals were located on County Road 246 in Moulton where "their alleged owner had 'parked' and/or 'broken down' while in route to an unknown location."

In her affidavit, Carpenter notes that Nosey "was chained by her legs in such a manner that made it impossible for her to move and resulted in her having to stand in her own feces."

Carpenter goes on to claim that the animals didn't have food or water and the only shelters they had access to were the trailers in which they arrived.

The animals were then seized by court order on November 9 and Nosey was transported to The Elephant Sanctuary in Tennessee by November 10. Sanctuary officials would go onto say later that it costs about $5,900 per week to take care of Nosey.

Later that month on November 22, Liebel's attorney, William J. Underwood, from Tuscumbia, filed a motion to dismiss the case for a "lack of jurisdiction."

In the motion, Underwood argues the District Court doesn't have jurisdiction over exotic animals or matters worth more than $10,000. Underwood asserts that "An African elephant is worth more than $10,000."

Prosecutors challenged those assertions in later court filings saying in part that the motion to dismiss should be denied under the Alabama Rules of Civil Procedure: "the assertion of defenses by motion to dismiss, allowed in the circuit court by Rule 12(b), is not available in the district court."

They also argued that because the plaintiffs are not seeking damages, the $10,000 limit doesn't apply in this case. They also said they will be able to prove at the hearing on December 15 that the defendants have about 200 violations of the Animal Welfare Act.

Underwood then filed another motion to dismiss on December 1, arguing that the plaintiffs "have not put up a bond in the amount of $500,000 for the value of the animals." In a later motion to dismiss filed on December 14, Underwood said Nosey was worth $1 million.

Later on December 4, Underwood filed a request to inspect Nosey by himself, Liebel and Nosey's veterinarian, Dr. Mark Wilson, up until that point. He said the reason for the request was because they "received information alleging that 'Nosey' has lost part of her tusk and there is swelling on the right side of her face."'

Underwood goes onto say that they believe Nosey "is not receiving proper care, and in fact being mistreated, at The Elephant Sanctuary in Tennessee."

Judge Angela Terry granted part of the request and allowed Dr. Wilson to see Nosey. A followup letter asked for permission for Underwood to be part of the visit and argued that Dr. Wilson didn't want to perform the inspection alone and suggested that "Nosey, nor the people at The Elephant Sanctuary, will allow him to get close enough to the animal to inspect her properly."

Judge Terry granted the updated request.

That same day, December 4, People for Ethical Treatment of Animals, or PETA, sent a letter to Liebel and the Great American Family Circus.

In it, PETA announced their intent to sue Liebel and the circus within 60 days of sending the letter "unless the Liebels agree to Nosey's permanent transfer to a [Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries]-accredited sanctuary."

Since then, the defense has filed four more motions to dismiss, with three of them being filed Thursday afternoon, according to court records.

The bench trial is expected to proceed Friday morning at 9 a.m.

Huntsville
Clear
76° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 76°
Florence
Clear
78° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 55°
Feels Like: 78°
Fayetteville
Clear
75° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 51°
Feels Like: 75°
Decatur
Clear
76° wxIcon
Hi: 77° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 76°
Scottsboro
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 54°
Feels Like: 73°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 137564

Reported Deaths: 2399
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson19938351
Mobile13507293
Montgomery8866185
Tuscaloosa8837118
Madison798179
Shelby607449
Lee597161
Baldwin560650
Marshall397543
Calhoun355644
Etowah354845
Morgan333428
Houston293921
Elmore271948
DeKalb244321
St. Clair235936
Walker235485
Talladega217830
Limestone214420
Cullman191920
Dallas179826
Franklin179130
Autauga178727
Russell17683
Lauderdale175133
Colbert167726
Blount162115
Escambia161624
Jackson159712
Chilton159530
Covington140727
Dale140344
Coffee13716
Pike121611
Chambers117542
Tallapoosa117185
Clarke110316
Marion97529
Butler91740
Barbour8867
Winston75013
Marengo72620
Pickens67014
Randolph66613
Lowndes65927
Bibb65810
Hale64928
Geneva6444
Lawrence63425
Cherokee61713
Bullock60714
Clay5918
Monroe5908
Washington56012
Crenshaw54332
Perry5426
Conecuh53911
Wilcox53211
Henry5105
Macon48318
Fayette4689
Sumter43719
Cleburne3945
Lamar3822
Choctaw35112
Greene30515
Coosa1743
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 194611

Reported Deaths: 2420
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby31097466
Davidson26797311
Hamilton963495
Knox960579
Rutherford945290
Williamson536636
Sumner489598
Wilson356247
Putnam336541
Montgomery313344
Unassigned30444
Madison299265
Out of TN297727
Bradley297217
Sevier266415
Blount256324
Maury242725
Washington235538
Robertson223939
Sullivan223133
Hamblen194828
Tipton184519
Gibson172624
Trousdale16697
Hardeman158426
Wayne15015
Dyer142017
Bedford137317
Dickson128015
Coffee127713
Fayette122719
Cumberland121919
Weakley121620
Anderson121013
Obion120211
Loudon11996
Henderson119125
Carter118028
Greene116946
McMinn116325
Jefferson114414
Lawrence108913
Warren10777
Macon106721
Monroe106618
Hardin105516
Lauderdale100316
Haywood99821
Franklin99410
Lake9252
McNairy92518
Carroll91320
Roane9126
Bledsoe8624
White85510
Rhea85413
Hawkins82720
Cheatham8199
Marshall7815
Overton7706
Cocke75310
Smith74011
Johnson7323
Chester65011
Giles64417
Lincoln6331
Henry6309
Hickman6008
DeKalb57414
Marion5518
Fentress5463
Crockett54419
Decatur5347
Campbell4614
Claiborne4455
Polk40710
Grainger3943
Union3762
Benton3418
Jackson3325
Morgan3213
Grundy3176
Cannon2950
Unicoi2911
Humphreys2673
Sequatchie2441
Clay2355
Houston2343
Meigs2323
Stewart2212
Scott2192
Lewis2081
Moore1831
Van Buren1660
Perry1530
Pickett1262
Hancock1073

Community Events