Will US diplomats finally return to Havana, after a rash of mystery injuries?

More than three years after the Trump administration pulled diplomats from Cuba following a series of still unexplained health incidents, effectively closing the embassy, the Biden administration is considering restaffing the US diplomatic mission. That would be welcome news for many Cubans unable to get visas to the US. CNN's Patrick Oppmann reports from Havana.

Posted: Feb 19, 2021 12:02 PM
Updated: Feb 19, 2021 5:15 PM


As the State Department reviews the changes made to US policy during the Trump administration, whether to restaff the US embassy in Havana is emerging as a key question and challenge.

Near the end of then-President Obama's term in 2016, the newly reopened US embassy situated on Havana's seaside Malecón boulevard was a sought-after posting, with diplomats jockeying to serve in a country where American foreign service officers were making history as the US and Cuba repaired long frayed diplomatic ties.

But late that year, US diplomats in their homes and hotel rooms in Havana began experiencing unexplained symptoms, such as dizziness and pounding headaches. These sometimes were accompanied by an unidentified 'piercing directional noise' that sounded as if metal was being scraped across a floor.

Eventually 24 diplomats were diagnosed with brain damage that ranged from mild impairment to injuries 'so severe they may never be able to return to their previous jobs,' according to a newly declassified but heavily redacted 2018 State Department Accountability Review Board report.

What caused their injuries remains a mystery.

The State Department report, which was obtained by the National Security Archive research institute though a Freedom of Information Act request, concludes that the US government's response and investigation into the so-called Havana Syndrome may have been botched from the beginning.

'You see chaos, lack of organization, you see excessive secrecy, as the authors of the report put it, all of which compromised an initial investigation assessment of what was going on,' said Peter Kornbluh, a senior analyst with the National Security Archive.

Part of the secrecy surrounding the incidents likely had to do with the fact that CIA officers working under diplomatic cover were among the first US officials impacted by the incidents and the first to depart Havana.

According to a timeline in the State Department report, the CIA informed the State Department in September 2017 of 'its decision to withdraw its personnel from Havana for the foreseeable future.'

The line is a rare public admission of a CIA station operating at a US Embassy, Kornbluh said.

'The CIA doesn't want to admit what everybody basically already knows, that they do have a contingent of operatives in most significant countries where they are trying to obtain intelligence,' he said. 'Cuba and the United States have been in a spy versus spy confrontation since the time of the revolution.'

Two weeks after the CIA pulled its officers from Cuba, then-Secretary of State Rex Tillerson ordered a larger draw down of the embassy, according to the State Department report.

Tillerson's decision to reduce embassy staffing 'does not appear to have followed standard Department of State procedures and was neither preceded nor followed by any formal analysis of the risks and benefits of continued physical presence of U.S. government employees in Havana,' the report said.

'Of the many Department leaders interviewed by the Board, no one can explain why this has not happened,' the report said, before offering one possibility for why the State Department did not follow its own safety protocols, which is redacted in the released report.

The cause of the diplomats' injuries also stumped US law enforcement, lawmakers, scientists and the intelligence community.

US investigators looked at the possibility that sonic weapons, neurotoxins, infectious diseases and mass hysteria could have been the cause. Canada said some of their diplomats suffered similar symptoms and also ordered a draw-down of their embassy in Havana.

US diplomats in China and Russia reported similar unexplained sudden health problems, raising the specter that American government officials working overseas were being widely targeted.

In December, a US-government funded study by the National Academy of Sciences said that 'directed' microwave radiation was the most likely cause of symptoms observed in the affected diplomats working in Havana and China.

The study did not say what kind of device was capable of blanketing diplomats with microwave, or what countries possess that kind of previously unknown energy weapon.

Cuban investigators told CNN they did not agree with the study's conclusion. 'There is no physical possibility of a microwave weapon, penetrating hotel rooms, houses, causing brain damage without burning the skin, without burning other tissues. It from the scientific point, untenable,' said Dr. Mitchell Valdes-Sosa, of the Cuba Neuroscience Center, who has been coordinating a Cuban government task force on the incidents.

Independent scientists consulted by CNN said that while there could be secret government programs they were not aware of, as far as they knew, there were no energy weapons that were capable of causing the damage described by US diplomats.

The official Cuban stance has always been that there were no attacks. 'There was not a single evidence of an attack. There were symptoms,' Johana Tablada, the Deputy Director for US Affairs at the Cuban Foreign Ministry, told CNN 'It's very easy to establish what didn't happen and attacks did not happen. Most of the diplomatic community then and today remain confident and feel safe.'

Cuban government officials complained that while they allowed the FBI to visit the island to investigate the issue, US officials have shared little of the information they have gathered and, at times, insinuated that Cuba may be involved in a cover-up if an ally, like Russia, were behind the incidents.

Following the incidents and Trump's reversal of Obama's opening with Cuba, the US Embassy has become 'a ghost ship manned by a skeleton crew' as one US diplomat, who served there after the draw-down and was not authorized to speak to the media, told CNN.

The diplomat said that, following the incidents, foreign service officers working in Havana lived several people to a house for security reasons and usually stayed for short tours of six months or less, making it difficult for them to get their bearings or develop contacts on the communist-run island.

The Biden administration has said they are reviewing all of the Trump administration's changes to Cuba policy, including the decision to pull diplomats from the embassy in Havana. Secretary of State Antony Blinken has been briefed on the diplomats injuries and would soon appoint a senior official to coordinate 'continuing support to affected personnel,' said State Department spokesman Ned Price at briefing last week.

Many Cubans who have been unable to visit family in the US since the incidents, are also hopeful that Biden will send US diplomats back to the island and restore services that had been suspended.

Following the drawdown of the embassy in 2017, consular services in Havana have been all but cut off for Cubans seeking visas to visit or emigrate to the United States. Thousands of Cubans have instead had to travel to third countries like Guyana to apply for visas.

Cuban illustrator Victor Alfonso Cedeño said he was turned down after he applied for an emergency medical visa from the embassy in 2020 so he could receive treatment in the US for a rare cancer he is suffering from.

'The answer we got was they couldn't receive the request because the consulate was closed,' he said 'Even though it's a medical situation, a situation of life or death.

Through their attorney, some of the US diplomats impacted by the alleged incidents in Havana said they regretted that Cubans had paid a price for their unexplained illnesses.

Mark Zaid, who represents eight diplomats and spouses that became sick in Havana, said that while he believes they were the victim of some kind of action by a US foreign adversary, Cuba was likely not directly responsible.

'It's unfortunate. I kind of look at the Cubans as second tier victims in this case. I know my clients, the State Department people who were there, they only have absolute praise,' Zaid told CNN. 'They thought things were going so great down there and would only want relationships to normalize and improve again.'

Huntsville/Redstone
Clear
42° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 37°
Feels Like: 42°
Muscle Shoals
Partly Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 40°
Huntsville/Madison
Clear
36° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 36°
Decatur
Clear
41° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 41°
Fort Payne
Partly Cloudy
33° wxIcon
Hi: 68° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 29°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 499819

Reported Deaths: 10148
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson720331403
Mobile36423741
Madison32708469
Tuscaloosa24457422
Montgomery22805523
Shelby22276219
Baldwin19935289
Lee15083161
Calhoun13963296
Morgan13801255
Etowah13419327
Marshall11460215
Houston10130264
Elmore9515190
Limestone9440139
St. Clair9057228
Cullman9000183
Lauderdale8630214
DeKalb8509175
Talladega7647165
Walker6601260
Jackson6552104
Autauga634792
Blount6256128
Colbert6010121
Coffee5261104
Dale4685107
Russell408134
Franklin400879
Covington3999107
Chilton3922104
Escambia379573
Tallapoosa3637143
Clarke344553
Chambers3434111
Dallas3428142
Pike293173
Marion288996
Lawrence286287
Winston258668
Bibb246558
Marengo245357
Geneva240670
Pickens226357
Barbour213951
Hale212969
Fayette202857
Butler201666
Henry183741
Cherokee178240
Monroe166739
Randolph165441
Washington157136
Macon147845
Crenshaw146955
Clay146254
Cleburne140341
Lamar133933
Lowndes133151
Wilcox123125
Bullock117736
Conecuh107224
Perry106427
Sumter101032
Coosa90324
Greene88932
Choctaw56123
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 783484

Reported Deaths: 11547
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby880221518
Davidson82248874
Knox46569589
Hamilton40761463
Rutherford38847388
Williamson25536204
Sumner21597320
Montgomery17563213
Out of TN1726097
Wilson16662211
Unassigned15872126
Sullivan14527275
Blount14213185
Bradley13111141
Washington12856234
Maury12284162
Sevier12182165
Putnam10671170
Madison10143232
Robertson9043121
Anderson8113158
Hamblen8097166
Greene7317145
Tipton6986103
Coffee6442115
Dickson6303106
Gibson6204141
Cumberland6141123
Carter6004155
McMinn597593
Roane595096
Bedford5848120
Loudon574566
Jefferson5729119
Lawrence558283
Monroe540691
Warren533777
Hawkins530298
Dyer5250101
Franklin477185
Fayette469373
Obion437195
Lincoln416762
Rhea416373
Cocke404696
Cheatham398744
Marshall393157
Campbell383759
Weakley380060
Giles375997
Henderson362674
Carroll349481
White340366
Hardeman339465
Macon337973
Hardin332463
Lauderdale310043
Henry301875
Marion296345
Scott289144
Wayne288830
Overton286758
Claiborne285369
McNairy269353
Hickman267941
DeKalb267651
Haywood265260
Smith258336
Grainger245246
Trousdale240122
Morgan231438
Fentress230344
Johnson217538
Chester202748
Bledsoe201410
Crockett197447
Unicoi182247
Polk179822
Cannon178930
Union174234
Grundy170530
Lake167926
Sequatchie157727
Humphreys155821
Decatur154437
Benton151339
Lewis147625
Meigs127023
Jackson125734
Stewart124825
Clay107231
Houston103932
Perry103628
Moore94716
Van Buren79820
Pickett74823
Hancock50012

Community Events