SEVERE WX : Freeze Watch View Alerts

The Arizona Supreme Court ruled two business owners did not have to make invitations for a same-sex wedding

A 2013 Phoenix law that adds "sexual orientation, gender identity or expression" to the city's nondiscrimination ordinance violated the freedom of speech and...

Posted: Sep 17, 2019 8:21 AM
Updated: Sep 17, 2019 1:00 PM

A 2013 Phoenix law that adds 'sexual orientation, gender identity or expression' to the city's nondiscrimination ordinance violated the freedom of speech and religious beliefs of two business owners, the Arizona Supreme Court said in a 4-3 ruling Monday.

Wedding invitation designers Joanna Duka and Breanna Koski, owners of Brush & Nib Studio, filed a lawsuit to challenge the city ordinance out of fear they'd be put in jail for refusing to create custom invitations that 'celebrate same-sex marriage,' the court decision says.

The city ordinance prohibits public accommodations from discriminating against people of protected status -- which includes sexual orientation. But neither the state nor federal civil rights accommodation statutes 'lists sexual orientation as a legally protected status,' the decision says.

Both the owners are Christians and seek to operate their business 'consistent with their religious beliefs,' the court says.

'Duka and Koski's beliefs about same-sex marriage may seem old-fashioned, or even offensive to some,' the court decision reads. 'But the guarantees of free speech and freedom of religion are not only for those who are deemed sufficiently enlightened, advanced, or progressive. They are for everyone.'

The two women's work is inspired by their faith, Jonathan Scruggs, their attorney from Alliance Defending Freedom said Monday.

'Through their custom artwork they seek to convey messages that are consistent with their beliefs and as the court explained today, this means that while they create artwork for all people they cannot create custom artwork to celebrate and promote messages they disagree with,' Scruggs said.

'What matters is the message, not the person,' he added.

Duka also said after the ruling that the two would 'gladly serve everyone but we cannot create custom artwork celebrating certain events.'

The owners sued in 2016 but lost their case in the Maricopa County Superior Court in 2017 and the Arizona Court of Appeals in 2018.

The new ruling is narrow, applying to only this business, and did not strike down the city's law, said Eric Fraser, the attorney who argued on behalf of the city.

'Freedom won'

Shortly after the ruling, Phoenix Mayor Kate Gallego said the court's decision was 'not a win but it is not a loss.'

'We will continue to have a debate over equality in this community,' she said, adding that the city's non-discrimination ordinance still stands. 'We will not stop with our fight.'

The mayor also said the case was never about one business but whether 'we would accept discrimination in our community.'

'A core tenet of our nation is freedom of religion but freedom of religion does not mean freedom to discriminate. Personal convictions cannot be used as an excuse for outward bigotry,' the mayor said. 'If you serve someone in your community, you should serve all people in our community.'

But attorney Scruggs said in a separate news conference the decision meant 'freedom won.'

'Everyone should enjoy the freedom to peacefully live out their beliefs,' he said. 'This ruling transcends this particular subject matter. It protects atheist musicians from being forced to perform at Easter services. It protects LGBT web designers from being forced to create websites criticizing same-sex marriage.'

Having that freedom means being able to 'peacefully live and work according to their beliefs without fear of unjust punishment,' Duka said.

'We brought our case to protect this freedom not just for us, but for all Americans,' she added.

License to discriminate

In a dissenting opinion, Judge Christopher P. Staring wrote he was concerned that 'ironically, today's holding could be relied on to discriminate against individuals based on their religion and religious beliefs.'

That's the concern echoed by the Human Rights Campaign, which called the ruling 'a license to discriminate.'

'Today's decision could also open the door for discrimination against other communities protected by the ordinance including religious minorities and women. LGBTQ Arizonans pay taxes, own businesses, serve in our military and contribute to our economy, and they deserve a government that stands with them,' the organization's Deputy Campaign Director Justin Unga said in a statement.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Arizona called the decision 'disappointing,' but emphasized the ruling was not a 'blanket license' for businesses to discriminate, but was specific only to the Phoenix business.

'We'll keep fighting to ensure protections for LGBT Arizonans so that no one can be fired from their job, denied a place to live, or be turned away from a business simply because of who they are and who they love,' ACLU of Arizona Policy Director Darrell Hill said in a statement.

Huntsville
Broken Clouds
59° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 59°
Florence
Clear
60° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 51°
Feels Like: 60°
Fayetteville
Clear
59° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 59°
Decatur
Clear
59° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 59°
Scottsboro
Clear
59° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 59°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 162720

Reported Deaths: 2735
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson24088384
Mobile17166319
Tuscaloosa10641142
Montgomery10576205
Madison961998
Shelby766067
Baldwin688871
Lee666965
Calhoun480663
Marshall450051
Etowah444553
Morgan442835
Houston426535
DeKalb357929
Elmore329258
St. Clair313843
Limestone300333
Walker290293
Talladega277737
Cullman271925
Lauderdale243743
Jackson228218
Autauga214131
Colbert212532
Franklin210732
Blount203925
Russell19993
Chilton192632
Dallas189427
Dale186252
Coffee185111
Covington178729
Escambia176031
Clarke139117
Tallapoosa138587
Chambers138147
Pike137014
Marion111831
Barbour10569
Marengo105322
Butler102041
Geneva9597
Winston95313
Pickens90018
Lawrence89933
Bibb86615
Randolph85316
Hale78330
Cherokee76915
Clay76712
Washington75912
Henry7366
Lowndes72328
Monroe66310
Bullock65117
Crenshaw61630
Fayette60413
Perry6026
Cleburne5819
Conecuh57313
Wilcox57212
Macon55020
Lamar5255
Sumter48721
Choctaw39512
Greene34616
Coosa2193
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 259488

Reported Deaths: 3341
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby37618571
Davidson32908350
Knox1330196
Rutherford12485116
Hamilton12251111
Williamson749657
Sumner6439117
Wilson495064
Putnam463859
Montgomery442861
Out of TN430436
Sullivan410052
Madison392780
Washington387758
Bradley372923
Maury363039
Blount355441
Sevier353423
Robertson270243
Hamblen256950
Tipton250123
Dyer236338
Unassigned23047
Gibson223449
Coffee201428
Hardeman193933
Greene192755
Obion186527
Anderson184816
Bedford180522
Trousdale17949
Dickson179119
Fayette177427
Lawrence173220
McMinn172939
Carter172136
Cumberland169827
Loudon169713
Wayne16237
Jefferson162224
Weakley161926
Monroe153629
Warren152011
Lauderdale150717
Roane14478
Hardin144423
Henderson144326
Macon138425
Franklin135124
Haywood133428
Hawkins128629
Overton126825
White126615
Johnson12118
Marshall120512
Carroll118127
Cocke116716
McNairy116330
Rhea115121
Cheatham112012
Campbell111613
Bledsoe10404
Smith104014
Giles102238
Lake9924
Lincoln9514
Fentress94812
Crockett91722
Henry84512
Hickman84115
Marion82613
DeKalb79018
Chester74416
Decatur68211
Grainger6414
Grundy60013
Union5604
Claiborne5498
Polk53813
Unicoi4865
Jackson4778
Humphreys4694
Lewis4586
Morgan4587
Benton44110
Cannon4362
Houston43117
Clay42216
Scott4165
Sequatchie3702
Stewart35613
Perry3508
Meigs3396
Pickett2879
Moore2862
Van Buren2132
Hancock1273

Community Events