As Robert Mueller writes his report, a potential battle brews over obstruction of justice

As special counsel Robert Mueller wraps up his Russia probe, investigators have focused on conflicting publi...

Posted: Jan 11, 2019 11:56 AM
Updated: Jan 11, 2019 11:56 AM

As special counsel Robert Mueller wraps up his Russia probe, investigators have focused on conflicting public statements by President Donald Trump and his team that could be seen as an effort to influence witnesses and obstruct justice, according to people familiar with the investigation.

The line of questioning adds to indications that Mueller views false or misleading statements to the press or to the public as obstruction of justice. That could set up a potential flashpoint with the White House and the Trump legal team should that become part of any final report from the Mueller investigation.

Continents and regions

Crime, law enforcement and corrections

Criminal offenses

Eastern Europe

Europe

Government and public administration

Investigations

Political Figures - US

Politics

Robert Mueller

Russia

Russia meddling investigation

2016 Presidential election

Adam Schiff

Criminal law

Donald Trump

Elections (by type)

Elections and campaigns

Government bodies and offices

Government departments and authorities

Government organizations - US

Justice departments

Law and legal system

Legal services

Political candidates

Rod Rosenstein

US Congress

US Federal elections

US federal government

US Presidential elections

White House

Donald Trump, Jr.

Mueller hasn't addressed the issue publicly, but prosecutors have dropped hints that they view public statements as possibly key in influencing witnesses.

Court filings from the plea of Michael Cohen, the President's former personal lawyer, included allegations related to false public statements -- not usually considered illegal since they aren't made directly to investigators. A December sentencing memo filed by Mueller's office notes that Cohen's lies were amplified in public statements, "including to other potential witnesses." The memo said this was done partly "in the hopes of limiting the investigation into possible Russian interference in the 2016 US presidential election -- an issue of heightened national interest."

The President's legal team took notice of the Cohen plea documents and believe the special counsel is pursuing a thin legal theory when it comes to potentially criminalizing public statements, a source briefed on the matter said. They believe the President's comments are protected under the First Amendment and that there's a difference between a plea deal and the President's position, which is to fight the allegations.

In a tweet Thursday night, Trump attorney Rudy Giuliani slammed the special counsel's team.

"Read CNN article that (Mueller) wants to use the President's public comments as part of an obstruction claim. According to this latest oppressive legal theory you can't even defend yourself," Giuliani said.

Whenever Mueller's investigation concludes, the moment is expected to mark the beginning of a new political and legal fight over the probe's findings.

One of those key areas of dispute likely will center on obstruction of justice allegations, which the President's legal team has considered off-limits because they argue it pertains to matters covered under executive privilege. When Trump responded to written questions from Mueller before Thanksgiving, the President's lawyers refused to respond to any questions on obstruction.

While Mueller is widely expected to not try to bring charges against the President, following long-standing Justice Department legal guidelines, investigators could try to weave into their report examples of how the President used public statements to try to obstruct the investigation. The Mueller team's questioning also shows their interest in obstruction extends beyond the President's firing of FBI Director James Comey

One witness who worked closely with Trump told CNN that, based on the questions asked, it is clear Mueller is looking at the President's "changing stories" as a way to possibly show corrupt intent in the obstruction probe.

Prosecutors appear to be examining the President's public statements as well to determine whether there's an effort to try to influence other witnesses and cause other administration and former campaign officials to make false public statements.

That includes the President's role in crafting the misleading Air Force One statement in the summer of 2017 on the now infamous June 2016 Trump Tower meeting with Russians attended by Donald Trump Jr., the President's son-in-law Jared Kushner and then-campaign chairman Paul Manafort.

Another episode centers on Trump's attempt to have his then-White House counsel Don McGahn disavow articles reporting that McGahn threatened to quit over Trump's pressure to fire Mueller, according to one source familiar with the matter. McGahn refused to publicly say that the stories were false, which prompted more anger from the President.

The President publicly has said he wouldn't fire Mueller and hadn't thought about it, which other witnesses have told Mueller's investigators isn't true.

A fight over who will see Mueller's report

Meanwhile, as clues mount that Mueller is ending his multi-year investigation in the coming weeks, new political and legal fights are emerging over who will actually be able to read his findings.

It's a battle the White House and Congress are already preparing for to determine if any of the report Mueller produces goes to Congress or any part of it becomes public.

President Donald Trump wouldn't indicate Thursday whether he wants Mueller's final report to be made public, saying to reporters, "We'll have to see."

But behind the scenes at the White House, an intense effort is underway to keep a lot of what Mueller submits private. The new White House counsel, Pat Cipollone, has been beefing up his staff to deal with this fight, hiring 17 new lawyers including three deputy counsels, a senior administration official said. More could be hired.

Mueller's investigators have been reviewing more than a million pages of documents that the President and the White House legal team voluntarily turned over without waiving privilege.

Trump's legal team and Cipollone believe that a large portion of the information in Mueller's investigation should be protected by executive privilege. The Trump lawyers envision a heavily redacted version of the report to perhaps become public.

Silence from Mueller

For a year, the Trump lawyers and the Mueller team have held on-and-off discussions for a possible interview with Trump, though the President has been counseled not to talk. His lawyers have told the special counsel they will not agree to an in-person interview, the president's attorney Rudy Giuliani told CNN on Wednesday.

But the President agreed to answer a limited set of questions in writing regarding matters that occurred before the 2016 election. Those responses were submitted before Thanksgiving.

While Mueller indicated there were some follow-up questions, Trump's lawyers resisted and demanded to know which areas would need additional questions, Giuliani told CNN.

Another source familiar with the discussion said the special counsel has been told that the President won't answer any more questions.

The special counsel's office has not responded and there has been no discussion between the two sides since before Christmas, Giuliani said.

Mueller report already being written

Even as the investigation continues, the Mueller team has already begun writing parts of the report laying out the investigation's findings, sources familiar with the matter said.

One person who knows Mueller and soon-to-depart Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein said the expectation is that it will be an extremely detailed written analysis and finalized after the investigative work is concluded. This person said both Mueller and Rosenstein are proponents of a written work product, leading to the belief it will be a thorough report.

But the final product is unlikely to fall on Rosenstein's desk. If confirmed, Bill Barr, the President's pick for attorney general, will oversee the investigation and ultimately decide what happens to the report.

The Justice Department regulations governing the special counsel calls for Mueller to "provide the Attorney General with a confidential report explaining the prosecution or declination decisions reached by the Special Counsel" when his work is completed.

The special counsel's report is expected to answer a number questions that follow Rosenstein's order appointing him, including whether anyone in the Trump campaign illegally coordinated with Russians who interfered in the 2016 elections.

But investigators have also sought, through interviews and documents, to determine: whether Trump obstructed justice; whether Trump knew in advance about the Trump Tower meeting with Russians in June 2016; whether campaign contacts sought stolen Democratic Party emails; whether foreign money illegally came into the election; and what gave rise to the Republican Party changing its platform in 2016 on Russian intervention in Ukraine.

A public report is not a sure thing

The regulations don't require Mueller to share his findings with the public.

If Mueller and the Justice Department do not make the report public -- and if the White House wants to keep it largely secret -- Congress could issue a subpoena to try to force its release.

Democrats, who now control the House of Representatives, have said they will fight to make sure the report is made public.

California Rep. Adam Schiff, the top Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, told CNN recently he's prepared to do "everything possible so that the public has the advantage of as much of the information as it can."

"Now, there may be parts of the report that have to be redacted because they involved classified information or they involve grand jury material," Schiff said on CNN's "State of the Union with Jake Tapper" just before Christmas. "At the end of the day, this case is just too important to keep from the American people what it's really about."

One of the likely points of contention between Trump and congressional opponents is likely to center on whether the President obstructed justice with some of his actions during the investigation.

Trump's team refused to answer any obstruction-related questions. They've argued that this part of the probe goes to the heart of the President's constitutional responsibilities. That could make any effort by Democrats to focus on that issue more contentious. Trump's lawyers have even sought to resist answering questions about the transition period -- the period of time between the election and the inauguration -- arguing that it is part of the incoming administration and should also be covered by executive privilege.

But Schiff said that the administration has already set a precedent with its cooperation with Republicans in Congress investigating Trump's 2016 opponent Hillary Clinton.

"For the last two years, I have been warning the Justice Department, as they have been turning over tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of pages of investigative files in the Clinton e-mail investigation, that whatever precedent they were going to set, they were going to have to live by," Schiff said.

Huntsville
Clear
76° wxIcon
Hi: 88° Lo: 73°
Feels Like: 76°
Florence
Clear
78° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 73°
Feels Like: 81°
Fayetteville
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 73°
Decatur
Clear
74° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 74°
Scottsboro
Overcast
73° wxIcon
Hi: 92° Lo: 74°
Feels Like: 73°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 99926

Reported Deaths: 1781
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson13258244
Mobile10517207
Montgomery6835149
Madison544734
Tuscaloosa423076
Baldwin365125
Unassigned363064
Shelby330936
Marshall318937
Lee270047
Morgan241118
Etowah216232
DeKalb183013
Calhoun180717
Elmore173138
Walker153964
Houston141912
Russell13872
St. Clair135418
Limestone134913
Dallas133123
Franklin128820
Cullman122712
Colbert120716
Lauderdale118919
Autauga117421
Escambia108717
Talladega104814
Jackson10144
Tallapoosa86579
Chambers84438
Dale83525
Clarke82610
Blount8124
Chilton8097
Butler76736
Coffee7646
Covington73720
Pike7087
Marion58026
Barbour5765
Lowndes57324
Marengo56515
Hale47826
Bullock46611
Winston45711
Perry4454
Washington44312
Bibb4425
Wilcox43210
Monroe4215
Pickens4049
Randolph40310
Conecuh39310
Sumter36418
Lawrence3512
Macon33914
Crenshaw3265
Choctaw28712
Cherokee2758
Henry2643
Clay2635
Geneva2631
Greene25211
Lamar2292
Fayette2125
Cleburne1271
Coosa1033
Out of AL00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 123914

Reported Deaths: 1233
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby23485308
Davidson20722217
Rutherford658955
Hamilton622053
Knox468540
Williamson357725
Sumner344972
Unassigned31424
Out of TN294714
Wilson232123
Bradley195613
Montgomery195213
Sevier18947
Putnam178518
Trousdale15836
Robertson156720
Hamblen140514
Blount131411
Washington12772
Maury12727
Tipton121110
Madison116018
Sullivan103714
Hardeman93017
Bedford92811
Macon86013
Lake7920
Loudon7493
Gibson7266
Bledsoe7081
Fayette7028
Dickson6982
Anderson6936
Dyer6638
Henderson6043
Cheatham5997
Jefferson5844
Obion5794
Lawrence5756
McMinn55320
Coffee5483
Rhea5382
Warren5334
Carter5246
Lauderdale5148
Haywood5106
Greene5048
Roane4852
Hawkins4837
Hardin4828
Cocke4783
Weakley4634
Cumberland4586
Smith4554
Monroe4529
Giles38513
McNairy3815
DeKalb3652
Franklin3324
Carroll3253
Lincoln3091
Marshall3044
White2945
Henry2900
Johnson2850
Claiborne2760
Hickman2730
Crockett2695
Campbell2541
Wayne2282
Marion2274
Chester2232
Decatur2163
Polk2073
Grainger2000
Overton1981
Unicoi1690
Union1620
Benton1591
Cannon1510
Jackson1291
Humphreys1283
Morgan1261
Scott1220
Grundy1142
Meigs1060
Sequatchie1060
Fentress960
Hancock812
Perry810
Clay780
Stewart780
Lewis741
Moore610
Houston590
Pickett371
Van Buren360

Community Events