Attorney petitions Supreme Court to declare Rod Rosenstein acting attorney general

In a highly unusual move, lawyer Tom Goldstein asked the US Supreme Court on Friday evening to declare Deput...

Posted: Nov 17, 2018 1:38 PM
Updated: Nov 17, 2018 1:38 PM

In a highly unusual move, lawyer Tom Goldstein asked the US Supreme Court on Friday evening to declare Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein as the acting attorney general, instead of Matthew Whitaker who currently holds the job.

Goldstein also represented Maryland's Attorney General in a similar court filing at the district court level earlier this week.

Continents and regions

Eastern Europe

Europe

Government and public administration

Government bodies and offices

Government organizations - US

Investigations

Law and legal system

Political Figures - US

Politics

Rod Rosenstein

Russia

Russia meddling investigation

US federal court system

US federal government

US Supreme Court

Matt Whitaker

US Congress

US House of Representatives

Appointments

White House

Goldstein's motion was filed in connection with a gun rights case that is before the Supreme Court as a petition for a writ of certiorari, meaning the nine Justices will meet in conference at a date still to be determined to decide whether to hear it. The case is Barry Michaels v. Whitaker, which was automatically renamed from Michaels v. Sessions following Whitaker's appointment.

Since the attorney general is charged with enforcing all federal law, including the statutes in this gun rights case, the motion argues that the identity of the attorney general is imperative, and the rightful acting attorney general is Rod Rosenstein.

The motion urged the Supreme Court to immediately declare the proper acting attorney general since there "is a significant national interest in avoiding the prospect that every district and immigration judge in the nation could, in relatively short order, be presented with the controversy over which person to substitute as Acting Attorney General." And petitioners even left room for the Supreme Court to affirm Whitaker's appointment saying, "Even if this Court now determines that the President in fact validly appointed Mr. Whitaker as Acting Attorney General, that ruling would equally benefit the administration of justice by removing the cloud of uncertainty over the appointment and by resolving the burgeoning number of challenges to it."

"We do want Rosenstein named Acting Attorney General," Goldstein said. "But we say to the court, even if we're wrong, it sure would be better for everybody to know the answer to that because this has turned into a mess."

Similar motions challenging Whitaker's appointment have been filed in other cases, including by the state of Maryland in its Affordable Care Act lawsuit, and by a private attorney in Missouri representing a client charged with wire fraud. Last week, the judge overseeing Roger Stone associate Andrew Miller's motion to quash, indicated attorneys would likely be asked to file new briefs adjusting their arguments to reflect Whitaker's new position.

It is unclear if the Justices will even consider this separate motion, since they have not agreed to hear the underlying case. Michaels' attorney petitioned the Supreme Court on October 18 and the court recently extended the government's time to respond to mid-December, meaning the Court won't decide whether to hear arguments on the case until after that time. Four justices must vote to hear the case in order for oral arguments to be scheduled.

But Goldstein was optimistic the Justices could weigh in on this motion even before deciding whether to hear arguments on the underlying case. "The motion doesn't have anything to do with the cert process," Goldstein said. "The Justices are used to dealing with motions at different stages of the case. We don't expect that the will hold the motion up pending the decision on the cert petition."

The motion contends that Whitaker's appointment violates federal law and the Constitution. It argues that the Constitution's Appointments Clause mandates that all principal officers, including the attorney general, must be Senate confirmed, and that the Trump administration should have followed the Attorney General Succession Act when naming Sessions' replacement. The AG Succession Act provides that in the case of the vacancy of the office of Attorney General, the deputy attorney general would exercise all duties of the office. The Trump administration has maintained that Whitaker's appointment is valid under the Federal Vacancies Reform Act.

On Wednesday, the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel issued a defense of President Donald Trump's controversial appointment of Whitaker, offering several reasons why the appointment is constituent with the Constitution. The 20-page memo asserted that (1) the appointment is consistent with the plain terms of the Vacancies Reform Act, "because he had been serving in the Department of Justice at a sufficiently senior pay level for over a year" as the statute requires; (2) because Whitaker is only serving on a temporary basis, he wasn't required to be confirmed by the senate ahead of his selection last week; and (3) even though is a separate statute exists that provides a succession plan at DOJ, the President can choose someone else consistent with the Vacancies Act.

On Thursday, the top Democrats on the House and Senate Judiciary committees and the top Democrat on the House intelligence committee released a statement criticizing the Office of Legal Counsel's reasoning.

"There should be bipartisan concern that this will embolden the future use of temporary appointments for illegitimate purposes. That's not what the framers or Congress intended," the statement said. "The attorney general must be Senate confirmed, plain and simple. This can't be allowed to stand."

Huntsville
Few Clouds
63° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 63°
Florence
Broken Clouds
64° wxIcon
Hi: 85° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 64°
Fayetteville
Broken Clouds
63° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 63°
Decatur
Clear
60° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 64°
Feels Like: 60°
Scottsboro
Overcast
59° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 63°
Feels Like: 59°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 153016

Reported Deaths: 2633
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson22720374
Mobile14405314
Tuscaloosa10066137
Montgomery9820196
Madison907894
Shelby715361
Lee646165
Baldwin644369
Marshall431048
Calhoun416059
Etowah412249
Morgan400033
Houston365532
DeKalb325428
Elmore312852
St. Clair283842
Limestone273630
Walker269993
Talladega259135
Cullman231024
Lauderdale212540
Jackson205515
Autauga202130
Franklin201731
Colbert193330
Russell19053
Blount187325
Dallas186027
Chilton182632
Escambia171428
Coffee16829
Covington166629
Dale163851
Chambers133043
Pike131313
Tallapoosa129587
Clarke127317
Marion105029
Butler99840
Barbour9969
Marengo98222
Winston90613
Geneva8447
Lawrence81131
Pickens81117
Randolph80514
Bibb80114
Hale74830
Cherokee72314
Clay72212
Lowndes70228
Henry6386
Bullock63717
Monroe63610
Washington62312
Crenshaw59830
Perry5816
Wilcox55912
Fayette55713
Conecuh55613
Cleburne5327
Macon53020
Sumter46821
Lamar4595
Choctaw38712
Greene34016
Coosa1993
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 235861

Reported Deaths: 2970
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby34739553
Davidson30155328
Knox1208187
Hamilton11289104
Rutherford11165107
Williamson670751
Sumner5715107
Wilson445553
Putnam423054
Montgomery393351
Out of TN376135
Unassigned37554
Madison366579
Bradley344722
Sullivan332146
Sevier322421
Washington318244
Blount317032
Maury311236
Robertson251040
Hamblen236543
Tipton223522
Gibson207838
Dyer207126
Hardeman180432
Coffee178320
Trousdale17447
Obion166420
Bedford160620
Anderson159613
Fayette159622
Dickson159119
Greene157551
Wayne15697
Loudon156610
McMinn154232
Cumberland153624
Lawrence150518
Jefferson148320
Weakley145325
Carter143932
Monroe138227
Henderson137325
Warren136810
Lauderdale134517
Hardin133619
Macon126924
Franklin123416
Roane12247
Haywood120026
Overton115211
White112214
Hawkins111724
Johnson11157
Carroll110724
McNairy109626
Marshall10638
Rhea105916
Bledsoe9944
Cheatham98211
Lake9763
Smith95412
Cocke95212
Giles91134
Campbell8997
Fentress8698
Lincoln8302
Crockett80221
Henry75310
Hickman74513
Chester71514
Marion7159
DeKalb68616
Decatur64511
Grainger5464
Grundy52510
Union5142
Claiborne5066
Polk47613
Jackson4225
Humphreys4194
Morgan4167
Benton3969
Houston39215
Cannon3902
Clay37913
Unicoi3732
Lewis3582
Scott3444
Sequatchie3304
Stewart3128
Meigs2975
Perry2531
Pickett2505
Moore2492
Van Buren1951
Hancock1123

Community Events