SEVERE WX : Wind Advisory View Alerts

Trump's bogus birthright citizenship gambit

Call it what it is: a desperate midterm election Hail Mary -- President Donald Trump floating a proposal to ...

Posted: Oct 30, 2018 7:51 PM
Updated: Oct 30, 2018 7:51 PM

Call it what it is: a desperate midterm election Hail Mary -- President Donald Trump floating a proposal to eliminate birthright citizenship by executive order.

Let's cut to the chase: This literally can't happen.

Barack Obama

Citizenship and naturalization

Continents and regions

Donald Trump

Executive orders

Government and public administration

Government bodies and offices

Immigration, citizenship and displacement

International relations and national security

North America

Political Figures - US

Politics

The Americas

United States

US federal government

White House

In the President's way is a little thing called the Constitution, which he swore under oath to uphold.

Birthright citizenship is a hot-button issue for anti-immigration activists, adding to Trump's intentionally toxic rhetoric about a migrant "invasion."

But birthright citizenship is embedded in the 14th Amendment of the US Constitution, which says, in part: "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States."

This was passed in the wake of the Civil War, to ensure that slaves born in the United States were granted full citizenship, no matter the state laws.

That's also one reason the 14th Amendment has been a perennial obsession of white nationalists and right-wing militia groups, such as the sovereign citizen movement.

But rarely if ever has this wingnut argument made its way to the Oval Office.

Play to the base prejudice aside, the President cannot undo the Constitution. That's basic separation of powers stuff.

The President told Axios -- which seemed tipped off to ask the question by the White House in advance of the launch of its HBO special series -- that unnamed advisers had told him he could overturn birthright citizenship through the legislature or by executive order.

This is BS. No adviser with a passing understanding of the US government would seriously suggest this. Far more likely is that Trump was floating a trial balloon to change the national conversation and inflame the base.

But this trial balloon is particularly ironic given the conservative movement's obsession with Obama-era executive orders, which it loudly argued marked an assault on the Constitution, calling him "King Obama" -- and much worse. In contrast, they claimed to be "constitutional conservatives" -- faithful to the vision of the Founding Fathers.

There's nothing particularly wrong with executive orders -- George Washington and Thomas Jefferson used them and they ballooned under Republicans Ulysses S. Grant and Teddy Roosevelt. In fact, Barack Obama used fewer executive orders than his predecessors George W. Bush, Bill Clinton and Ronald Reagan -- though you'd never know it from watching Fox News during the last presidency. And then there's this: Trump is on pace to exceed the number of Obama executive orders if he serves two terms. (Obama issued an average of 35 executive orders a year. If Trump were to issue no more executive orders this year, his average would be 43 per year.)

But having raised the issue as a threat to the Constitution, it is absurd that Republicans are now ignoring or even encouraging the action because a president of their party is in power. Even more absurd is the fact that Trump has been issuing executive orders while Republicans have unified control of government. Such orders are most rationally used to overcome an obstructive opposition in Congress.

Another fundamental Trump mis-truth is the idea that birthright citizenship is unique to the United States. It's not. Canada and Mexico, and more than two dozen other countries, have similar statutes.

Vice President Mike Pence tried to support Trump when he said Tuesday, "We all cherish the language of the 14th Amendment, but the Supreme Court of the United States has never ruled on whether or not the language of the 14th Amendment, 'subject to the jurisdiction thereof,' applies specifically to people who are in the country illegally."

But Republican Rep. Justin Amash was right when he tweeted, "A president cannot amend Constitution or laws via executive order. Concept of natural-born citizen in #14thAmendment derives from natural-born subject in Britain. Phrase 'and subject to the jurisdiction thereof' excludes mainly foreign diplomats, who are not subject to U.S. laws."

Sen. Mark Warner, a Democrat, made the point bipartisan: "This notion that he can simply violate the Constitution by executive order, let's face it, no serious legal scholar thinks that's real."

As we've seen, some Trump defenders will point to "anchor baby tourism" as a problem in need of a solution. There are indeed properties that cater to this abuse of birthright citizenship. Trump should know -- his own Trump-branded properties in Florida are often advertised by third parties to expectant Russian parents, as The Daily Beast reported back in 2017 when I was editor-in-chief. Physician, heal thyself. And the President can start by cracking down on the practice through law enforcement rather than threatening to ignore the Constitution.

But just because the President can't unilaterally override the Constitution doesn't mean he won't try. He could sign an executive order, possibly against the legal advice of his Justice Department and immediately have the proposal blocked by suits from several states attorneys general. Because this isn't a jump ball, the issue will fail on the merits when it reaches the courts.

By then the President may have milked this for political benefit. So make no mistake -- this is play-to-the-base panic, a classic Trump attempt to distract and deflect. Don't fall for it.

Huntsville
Partly Cloudy
77° wxIcon
Hi: 79° Lo: 62°
Feels Like: 78°
Florence
Mostly Cloudy
78° wxIcon
Hi: 80° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 79°
Fayetteville
Partly Cloudy
77° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 58°
Feels Like: 78°
Decatur
Partly Cloudy
76° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 62°
Feels Like: 76°
Scottsboro
Partly Cloudy
74° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 55°
Feels Like: 74°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 530744

Reported Deaths: 10978
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson764931522
Mobile40959804
Madison34735503
Tuscaloosa25749452
Montgomery24327589
Shelby23425249
Baldwin21123308
Lee15873171
Calhoun14496314
Morgan14288279
Etowah13826353
Marshall12213223
Houston10561281
Elmore10052205
Limestone9958151
Cullman9659193
St. Clair9652243
Lauderdale9420241
DeKalb8828186
Talladega8220176
Walker7231277
Autauga6918108
Jackson6809112
Blount6656137
Colbert6296134
Coffee5509119
Dale4830111
Russell440738
Chilton4284112
Franklin425682
Covington4118118
Tallapoosa4026152
Escambia393376
Chambers3560123
Dallas3547151
Clarke351061
Marion3116101
Pike310877
Lawrence300298
Winston274272
Bibb260564
Marengo249664
Geneva249477
Pickens234361
Barbour230757
Hale222877
Butler215969
Fayette212262
Henry188744
Cherokee184645
Randolph180141
Monroe177340
Washington167239
Macon158950
Clay156156
Crenshaw152257
Cleburne148941
Lamar142535
Lowndes138753
Wilcox127030
Bullock123041
Conecuh110329
Perry107526
Coosa107228
Sumter104432
Greene92334
Choctaw60624
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 852841

Reported Deaths: 12255
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby956561619
Davidson89355933
Knox50675635
Hamilton44280494
Rutherford43046434
Williamson28015217
Sumner24012349
Montgomery20255225
Wilson18804234
Out of TN1840797
Unassigned16998134
Sullivan16794294
Blount15490193
Bradley15032150
Washington14597245
Maury13499172
Sevier13391175
Putnam11396175
Madison11168242
Robertson9756131
Anderson8760172
Hamblen8610173
Greene7877155
Tipton7359103
Coffee6905121
Dickson6840110
Cumberland6734132
Carter6634158
Gibson6526146
McMinn650898
Bedford6506128
Roane6282105
Jefferson6211124
Loudon613069
Hawkins6077107
Lawrence593887
Monroe584095
Warren554881
Dyer5425106
Franklin515090
Fayette506877
Cheatham455355
Obion454196
Cocke450099
Lincoln435763
Rhea434875
Marshall419058
Campbell415463
Weakley412865
Giles3996100
Henderson378976
White364170
Macon361978
Carroll361683
Hardin357167
Hardeman352664
Lauderdale318944
Henry318576
Claiborne318273
Marion312347
Scott312345
Overton301161
Wayne296334
Hickman284046
McNairy282054
DeKalb279654
Smith277839
Haywood271162
Grainger262850
Morgan250139
Trousdale250122
Fentress241547
Johnson240739
Chester214351
Bledsoe214211
Polk207824
Unicoi203549
Crockett203248
Cannon192031
Union190734
Humphreys179927
Grundy179334
Lake170326
Sequatchie169829
Benton166540
Decatur158639
Lewis158126
Meigs139125
Stewart132528
Jackson132036
Clay110131
Houston109333
Perry106628
Moore101117
Van Buren84723
Pickett76024
Hancock58912

Community Events