STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Duck boat survivor Tia Coleman stunned by legal maneuver invoking 1851 law

Citing a maritime law from the 1850s, the companies that operated a duck boat that sank during a fierce stor...

Posted: Oct 18, 2018 10:46 AM
Updated: Oct 18, 2018 10:46 AM

Citing a maritime law from the 1850s, the companies that operated a duck boat that sank during a fierce storm in July, killing 17 people, have filed paperwork asking a federal court to rule they have little or no liability for the incident.

The companies said the legal maneuver, filed in Missouri, will consolidate the civil actions against them and they plan to mediate settlements with survivors and families of the victims.

2018 Missouri duck boat accident

Accidental fatalities

Accidents

Accidents, disasters and safety

Automotive industry

Business and industry sectors

Business, economy and trade

Continents and regions

Deaths and fatalities

Law and legal system

Marine transportation

Marine vessels

Midwestern United States

Misc people

Missouri

Motor vehicles

North America

Ship and boat accidents

Society

The Americas

Tia Coleman

Tour operators

Transportation and warehousing

Travel and tourism

Travel arrangements and reservations

United States

But one woman who survived the sinking as nine of her family members perished said the court filing finding her relatives "worthless is incredibly hurtful and insensitive."

Ripley Entertainment, which operates Branson Duck Vehicles, says in its court complaint filed Monday that an 1851 law limits its liability because the amphibious vessel was properly maintained and prepared for the voyage and after the sinking it is a total loss.

"Except as provided in section 30506 of this title, the liability of the owner of a vessel for any claim, debt, or liability described in subsection (b) shall not exceed the value of the vessel and pending freight," the law says.

A Ride the Ducks Branson vessel capsized and sank July 19 on a lake near Branson, Missouri, as a severe thunderstorm whipped up intense winds and waves. Seventeen people, aged 1 to 76, drowned, including one crew member.

Nine of the victims were members of Tia Coleman's family. Tia Coleman, who is from Indianapolis, Indiana, and her nephew survived.

"Anyone who cares about people or has any human decency should boycott Ripley and their attractions," she said Tuesday.

Ripley issued a statement that said it has been doing everything it could for the 14 survivors and the relatives of the deceased. The legal action is common in maritime disasters, the company said. Settlement talks will still take place, a spokeswoman said.

"We have reached out to those most impacted by the accident and offered to mediate their claims now," public relations manager Suzanne Smagala-Potts said. She said lawyers have scheduled mediation hearings or will do so.

One of Coleman's attorneys disputed that they have talked settlements.

"Ripley's claim that the lives of the family members they killed with their outrageous and criminal conduct are worthless is yet another insult to these grieving family members from the Ripley's organization," attorney Robert J. Mongeluzzi said. "Let us be clear, there have been no offers of settlement. None."

He predicted a federal judge will dismiss the complaint.

"Ripley's inhuman legal ploy will sink as fast as their death trap duck boat did," he said. "We will legally and factually demolish this frivolous claim."

Duck boats are amphibious vessels that travel on both land and water, and are popular among tourists in major cities. The boats' history dates to World War II, when such vessels were a common sight because of their versatility.

Tia Coleman filed a wrongful death lawsuit in September on behalf of her late husband and three children.

Earlier, the administrators of the estates of two other members of the Coleman family who died filed a wrongful death lawsuit seeking $100 million in damages from the companies.

An attorney representing the victims' estates said the boat's canopy entrapped the passengers and dragged them to the bottom of the lake.

The passengers might have survived, the attorney said, if the Branson operators had not ignored a 2002 National Transportation Safety Board recommendation that all duck boat canopies should be removed.

There are also a federal criminal investigation into the deadly sinking and a criminal probe by Missouri's attorney general.

The National Transportation Safety Board is investigating the cause of the sinking.

Huntsville
Scattered Clouds
81° wxIcon
Hi: 88° Lo: 72°
Feels Like: 86°
Florence
Clear
80° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 73°
Feels Like: 85°
Fayetteville
Clear
75° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 75°
Decatur
Clear
77° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 79°
Scottsboro
Overcast
75° wxIcon
Hi: 92° Lo: 73°
Feels Like: 75°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 99926

Reported Deaths: 1781
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson13258244
Mobile10517207
Montgomery6835149
Madison544734
Tuscaloosa423076
Baldwin365125
Unassigned363064
Shelby330936
Marshall318937
Lee270047
Morgan241118
Etowah216232
DeKalb183013
Calhoun180717
Elmore173138
Walker153964
Houston141912
Russell13872
St. Clair135418
Limestone134913
Dallas133123
Franklin128820
Cullman122712
Colbert120716
Lauderdale118919
Autauga117421
Escambia108717
Talladega104814
Jackson10144
Tallapoosa86579
Chambers84438
Dale83525
Clarke82610
Blount8124
Chilton8097
Butler76736
Coffee7646
Covington73720
Pike7087
Marion58026
Barbour5765
Lowndes57324
Marengo56515
Hale47826
Bullock46611
Winston45711
Perry4454
Washington44312
Bibb4425
Wilcox43210
Monroe4215
Pickens4049
Randolph40310
Conecuh39310
Sumter36418
Lawrence3512
Macon33914
Crenshaw3265
Choctaw28712
Cherokee2758
Henry2643
Clay2635
Geneva2631
Greene25211
Lamar2292
Fayette2125
Cleburne1271
Coosa1033
Out of AL00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 123914

Reported Deaths: 1233
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby23485308
Davidson20722217
Rutherford658955
Hamilton622053
Knox468540
Williamson357725
Sumner344972
Unassigned31424
Out of TN294714
Wilson232123
Bradley195613
Montgomery195213
Sevier18947
Putnam178518
Trousdale15836
Robertson156720
Hamblen140514
Blount131411
Washington12772
Maury12727
Tipton121110
Madison116018
Sullivan103714
Hardeman93017
Bedford92811
Macon86013
Lake7920
Loudon7493
Gibson7266
Bledsoe7081
Fayette7028
Dickson6982
Anderson6936
Dyer6638
Henderson6043
Cheatham5997
Jefferson5844
Obion5794
Lawrence5756
McMinn55320
Coffee5483
Rhea5382
Warren5334
Carter5246
Lauderdale5148
Haywood5106
Greene5048
Roane4852
Hawkins4837
Hardin4828
Cocke4783
Weakley4634
Cumberland4586
Smith4554
Monroe4529
Giles38513
McNairy3815
DeKalb3652
Franklin3324
Carroll3253
Lincoln3091
Marshall3044
White2945
Henry2900
Johnson2850
Claiborne2760
Hickman2730
Crockett2695
Campbell2541
Wayne2282
Marion2274
Chester2232
Decatur2163
Polk2073
Grainger2000
Overton1981
Unicoi1690
Union1620
Benton1591
Cannon1510
Jackson1291
Humphreys1283
Morgan1261
Scott1220
Grundy1142
Meigs1060
Sequatchie1060
Fentress960
Hancock812
Perry810
Clay780
Stewart780
Lewis741
Moore610
Houston590
Pickett371
Van Buren360

Community Events