The fight over defining soy and almond milk

Citizens are learning about the myriad abuses of industrialized animal agriculture, and they are seeking hea...

Posted: Oct 23, 2018 2:07 PM
Updated: Oct 23, 2018 2:07 PM

Citizens are learning about the myriad abuses of industrialized animal agriculture, and they are seeking healthier and more responsible alternatives. As a result, the demand for plant-based foods to replace meat, dairy and eggs is growing, which has agribusiness profiteers worried. Factory-farm lobbyists are pushing for new laws and regulations to slow down these emerging competitors, including efforts to control how words such as "milk" and "meat" can be used.

The dairy industry wants to prevent nondairy milks from being marketed as "milk," and has introduced federal legislation to ban using the word "milk" except to label "lacteal secretions." Industry operatives and lobbyists want to counteract declining sales by regulating marketing labels and speciously argue that people are confused by the word "milk" on packages of nondairy products. In fact, labels that specify the source of milk, such as "soy milk" or "almond milk," are more descriptive and clear, as they indicate the source of products, which are used in many of the same contexts as dairy milk. Consumers are not likely to be confused.

Agriculture

Agriculture, forestry, and commercial fishing

Animal farming and livestock

Animals

Business and industry sectors

Business, economy and trade

Consumer products

Dairy production

Dairy products

Environment and natural resources

Environmentalism

Food and beverage industry

Food and drink

Food production industry

Food products

Government and public administration

Government bodies and offices

Government organizations - US

Kinds of foods and beverages

Land use planning

Life forms

Real estate

Sustainable development

US Department of Agriculture

US federal departments and agencies

US federal government

Beverages

Non-dairy milks

Continents and regions

North America

The Americas

United States

Milk is produced by different mammals, including cows and goats, and from plants, including a wide range of nuts, seeds, grains and legumes. If agribusiness is truly concerned about accurate labeling and transparency, it should encourage all milks to be clearly labeled, and that includes milk from cows, which should be labeled "cows' milk." But transparency doesn't seem to be what the dairy industry is really after. In fact, the dairy industry doesn't want consumers to know or think about how cows' milk is produced, as evidenced by its support for "ag-gag" laws that undermine investigations, journalism and transparency in our food system to keep the animal abuse that occurs on industrial farms quiet.

Nonetheless, citizens are becoming aware of the human health risks and environmental threats of exploiting animals for food. Most people would prefer to support a more humane, sustainable and healthy food system, and our nation's food choices are beginning to reflect this. According to the US Department of Agriculture, per capita consumption of cows' milk dropped from 220 pounds per person in 1990 to 154 pounds in 2016. Meanwhile, the consumption of nondairy milks is increasing.

Instead of scaling down production in response to shrinking demand, dairies continue to overproduce cows' milk. According to the USDA, in 1998 each milk cow produced an average of 17,186 pounds of milk that year. Last year, that number reached 22,938 pounds despite per capita consumption dropping from 198 pounds to 149 pounds. The surplus is processed and stored, and even purchased by the USDA, which has a long history of bailing out and enabling this declining industry.

Because the gap between milk production and consumption has been widening in the United States, dairies now depend on exports, which are supported by government programs and policies. Agribusiness is among the most entrenched interests in Washington, and it has mastered the revolving-door culture of influence between government and private entities. For example, shortly after leaving his post as US agriculture secretary, Tom Vilsack was hired to head the US Dairy Export Council, which works to sell US dairy products around the world.

For decades, the dairy industry, along with other factory-farming interests, has invested heavily in the political system, and it is a perennial recipient of preferential policies and government subsidies.

And similar to the way dairy promoters want to control the term "milk," the slaughter industry wants to regulate the term "meat" so that plant-based burgers and other alternatives to animal flesh cannot use the term.

The industry is now lobbying in Washington and in states such as Missouri, where they've advanced a law to prevent the word "meat" from being used on anything other than the "edible portion of livestock or poultry carcass."

Like the dairy industry, the meat industry seems to oppose transparent and descriptive labels. Ironically, while the animal agriculture industry argues for accuracy, it commonly uses misleading euphemisms such as "harvesting" to describe animal slaughter. If the goal is to be clear and transparent, the flesh of slaughtered animals should actually be called "the flesh of slaughtered animals" or "a portion of animal carcass."

Animal agriculture is deeply entrenched, but its inhumane and irresponsible practices are outside the bounds of acceptable conduct. Factory-farm operators want to keep consumers in the dark, but awareness is growing, and citizens are demanding a more humane and sustainable food system. Innovative businesses are now producing plant foods to replace animal products. We can be far more efficient, and feed more people with fewer resources by eating plants directly instead of growing and harvesting crops to feed and fatten farm animals.

Rather than misleading consumers, undermining free speech and discouraging a discussion of unsavory truths in our industrial food system, agriculture needs to evolve. The good news is that despite regressive efforts by industry hard-liners, a growing number of businesses, including some with long traditions in animal agriculture, are investing in plant-based foods. They are working to provide nutritious food sustainably without causing needless violence. If we can live well without exploiting animals and causing unnecessary harm, why wouldn't we?

Huntsville
Overcast
67° wxIcon
Hi: 77° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 67°
Florence
Overcast
69° wxIcon
Hi: 79° Lo: 63°
Feels Like: 69°
Fayetteville
Overcast
66° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 66°
Decatur
Overcast
67° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 67°
Scottsboro
Overcast
68° wxIcon
Hi: 77° Lo: 60°
Feels Like: 68°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 134231

Reported Deaths: 2357
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson19441349
Mobile13271291
Montgomery8778179
Madison775480
Tuscaloosa7496119
Shelby584951
Lee582961
Baldwin516550
Marshall390944
Calhoun346641
Etowah342047
Morgan325428
Houston278123
Elmore263247
DeKalb239120
Walker228483
St. Clair227837
Talladega212728
Limestone206120
Cullman188519
Dallas177426
Franklin175529
Russell17442
Autauga173825
Lauderdale168233
Colbert163626
Blount159415
Escambia158425
Jackson154611
Chilton153531
Dale135444
Covington134427
Coffee13078
Pike11879
Chambers115142
Tallapoosa114685
Clarke107717
Marion95729
Butler91339
Barbour8577
Winston73712
Marengo70820
Lowndes65327
Pickens65114
Bibb64210
Randolph63713
Hale62828
Lawrence60922
Geneva5995
Bullock59814
Cherokee59115
Monroe5818
Clay5707
Washington55613
Perry5407
Conecuh53111
Crenshaw53132
Wilcox53111
Henry4865
Macon48020
Fayette4438
Sumter43419
Lamar3632
Choctaw34612
Cleburne3396
Greene30315
Coosa1673
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 187690

Reported Deaths: 2312
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby30460452
Davidson26252298
Hamilton928791
Knox918175
Rutherford915088
Williamson516536
Sumner475896
Wilson341844
Putnam320139
Montgomery302244
Out of TN296825
Unassigned29145
Bradley289317
Madison280061
Sevier257015
Blount247723
Maury230923
Washington223935
Robertson219035
Sullivan212133
Hamblen188525
Tipton178118
Trousdale16517
Gibson160922
Hardeman154826
Wayne14905
Bedford132017
Dyer131813
Dickson123515
Cumberland117518
Fayette117418
Coffee116613
Weakley115719
Anderson115312
Henderson115322
Carter114728
Obion11389
Loudon11356
Greene112943
McMinn110025
Jefferson109714
Macon103520
Warren10267
Monroe102217
Lawrence101211
Hardin100516
Lauderdale95915
Haywood95418
Franklin9518
Lake9142
Roane8724
Carroll85819
Bledsoe8494
McNairy84218
White8139
Cheatham80610
Rhea79812
Hawkins78316
Cocke7419
Marshall7415
Overton7135
Smith69810
Johnson6752
Henry6139
Chester60910
Lincoln6031
Giles58017
Hickman5585
DeKalb55213
Crockett52919
Marion5187
Decatur5037
Fentress4713
Claiborne4405
Campbell4314
Polk38210
Grainger3633
Union3471
Benton3349
Jackson3175
Morgan3113
Unicoi2831
Cannon2800
Grundy2685
Humphreys2443
Sequatchie2293
Meigs2233
Clay2205
Houston2083
Scott2072
Stewart1902
Lewis1851
Moore1641
Van Buren1600
Perry1490
Pickett1102
Hancock1063

Community Events