BREAKING NEWS Elementary school employee in Fayetteville tests positive for coronavirus Full Story

Prosecutors can't call Laquan McDonald a 'victim' in murder trial

Prosecutors are barred from calling...

Posted: Aug 16, 2018 11:05 AM
Updated: Aug 16, 2018 11:05 AM

Prosecutors are barred from calling Laquan McDonald, who was killed by a Chicago police officer, a "victim," at least until closing arguments, a judge ruled on Wednesday.

Chicago police Officer Jason Van Dyke, who is charged with first-degree murder and other firearm offenses, shot the 17-year-old in self-defense in October 2014, defense attorneys have argued.

Chicago

Chicago police department

Continents and regions

Court trials

Crime, law enforcement and corrections

Crimes against persons

Criminal law

Criminal offenses

Firearms

Homicide

Illinois

Jason Van Dyke

Laquan McDonald

Law and legal system

Law enforcement

Midwestern United States

Misc organizations

Misc people

Misconduct

Murder

North America

Police misconduct

Policing and police forces

Shootings

Society

The Americas

Trial and procedure

United States

Weapons and arms

Jeffrey Toobin

Cook County Judge Vincent Gaughan heard nearly two dozen motions from Van Dyke's defense attorneys to bar potential evidence and testimony the defense said could be prejudicial, including referring to McDonald's death as a homicide.

Prosecutor Jody Gleason argued Van Dyke is charged with first-degree murder, and there is a victim in the case. But Gaughan said there is someone who is dead but it's up to the jury to decide whether McDonald was a victim.

"Here we have the defense of self-defense. So, if it's justified, justified use of force, then there is no victim," Gaughan said. "Certainly, there is a person that's dead as a result of this tragic situation but that doesn't mean that the person is a victim legally."

Gaughan said prosecutors could use the term victim in closing arguments "if the evidence supports it."

CNN chief legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin said the judge's decision to bar use of the word "victim" is odd but probably not unprecedented.

"The main issue in the case is whether McDonald was a 'victim' or a threat to the officer. The judge could conclude that use of that word is prejudicial to the defendant. Many judges would see it differently, but I see his point," Toobin said in an email.

Toobin said he didn't foresee the omission of the word affecting the prosecution's case.

"The jury will understand that its job is to evaluate whether the shooting was justified," Toobin said.

Gaughan also ruled the prosecution could use the word homicide in court. He said forensic pathologists define homicide as death by another person.

Special Prosecutor Joseph McMahon said homicide is "a specific finding of the medical examiner and the defendant is charged with first-degree murder."

He argued the word "is not so loaded that it's unfairly prejudicial."

Van Dyke's trial is scheduled for September 5. He is the first Chicago officer charged with first-degree murder since 1980.

Van Dyke is white, and McDonald was black.

Dashcam video of the shooting contradicted nearly everything police said happened when McDonald was shot. The video showed McDonald walking away from police, holding a 4-inch knife, but not lunging toward officers, as police had said.

Van Dyke jumped out of his vehicle and pulled his gun, firing at McDonald six seconds after arriving on the scene. Van Dyke continued to shoot, unloading every round from his gun in 15 seconds.

The video also appeared to show McDonald's body being hit by bullets after he was on the ground. All 16 bullets struck McDonald.

After the incident, Van Dyke said he opened fire after McDonald lunged at him, "swinging the knife in an aggressive, exaggerated manner," and ignored the officer's orders to drop the knife. He said McDonald continued to grasp the knife, pointing it at him, as he tried to get up from the ground.

Officials said McDonald's partner and four other officers backed up his account, saying McDonald refused officers' orders and continued to advance toward them, waving the knife.

After the city's objections, 400 days after the incident, the dashcam video was released to the public, when a judge ordered its release in November 2015.

The shooting led to reforms and fueled a national conversation about police use of deadly force.

Gaughan on Wednesday denied a defense motion to suppress the dashcam video of the shooting. McMahon argued it is "a central piece of evidence."

"Certainly, you're going to be allowed to play the dashcam video," Gaughan said.

If convicted, Van Dyke could face up to life in prison.

Huntsville
Overcast
71° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 71°
Florence
Overcast
73° wxIcon
Hi: 74° Lo: 62°
Feels Like: 73°
Fayetteville
Overcast
70° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 60°
Feels Like: 70°
Decatur
Overcast
71° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 60°
Feels Like: 71°
Scottsboro
Overcast
73° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 73°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 134231

Reported Deaths: 2357
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson19441349
Mobile13271291
Montgomery8778179
Madison775480
Tuscaloosa7496119
Shelby584951
Lee582961
Baldwin516550
Marshall390944
Calhoun346641
Etowah342047
Morgan325428
Houston278123
Elmore263247
DeKalb239120
Walker228483
St. Clair227837
Talladega212728
Limestone206120
Cullman188519
Dallas177426
Franklin175529
Russell17442
Autauga173825
Lauderdale168233
Colbert163626
Blount159415
Escambia158425
Jackson154611
Chilton153531
Dale135444
Covington134427
Coffee13078
Pike11879
Chambers115142
Tallapoosa114685
Clarke107717
Marion95729
Butler91339
Barbour8577
Winston73712
Marengo70820
Lowndes65327
Pickens65114
Bibb64210
Randolph63713
Hale62828
Lawrence60922
Geneva5995
Bullock59814
Cherokee59115
Monroe5818
Clay5707
Washington55613
Perry5407
Conecuh53111
Crenshaw53132
Wilcox53111
Henry4865
Macon48020
Fayette4438
Sumter43419
Lamar3632
Choctaw34612
Cleburne3396
Greene30315
Coosa1673
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 187690

Reported Deaths: 2312
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby30460452
Davidson26252298
Hamilton928791
Knox918175
Rutherford915088
Williamson516536
Sumner475896
Wilson341844
Putnam320139
Montgomery302244
Out of TN296825
Unassigned29145
Bradley289317
Madison280061
Sevier257015
Blount247723
Maury230923
Washington223935
Robertson219035
Sullivan212133
Hamblen188525
Tipton178118
Trousdale16517
Gibson160922
Hardeman154826
Wayne14905
Bedford132017
Dyer131813
Dickson123515
Cumberland117518
Fayette117418
Coffee116613
Weakley115719
Anderson115312
Henderson115322
Carter114728
Obion11389
Loudon11356
Greene112943
McMinn110025
Jefferson109714
Macon103520
Warren10267
Monroe102217
Lawrence101211
Hardin100516
Lauderdale95915
Haywood95418
Franklin9518
Lake9142
Roane8724
Carroll85819
Bledsoe8494
McNairy84218
White8139
Cheatham80610
Rhea79812
Hawkins78316
Cocke7419
Marshall7415
Overton7135
Smith69810
Johnson6752
Henry6139
Chester60910
Lincoln6031
Giles58017
Hickman5585
DeKalb55213
Crockett52919
Marion5187
Decatur5037
Fentress4713
Claiborne4405
Campbell4314
Polk38210
Grainger3633
Union3471
Benton3349
Jackson3175
Morgan3113
Unicoi2831
Cannon2800
Grundy2685
Humphreys2443
Sequatchie2293
Meigs2233
Clay2205
Houston2083
Scott2072
Stewart1902
Lewis1851
Moore1641
Van Buren1600
Perry1490
Pickett1102
Hancock1063

Community Events