Fight to raise minimum wage wins court victory in Birmingham

A federal appeals court delivered a surprising victory Wednesday to supporters of the Fight for $15 campaign when it ...

Posted: Jul 26, 2018 2:12 PM
Updated: Jul 26, 2018 2:12 PM

A federal appeals court delivered a surprising victory Wednesday to supporters of the Fight for $15 campaign when it ruled that a lawsuit challenging the abolishment of a minimum wage hike can go forward.

The 11th US Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a lower court's dismissal of the lawsuit, which charged that Alabama legislators acted with "racial animus" when they abolished an attempt by Birmingham's majority black government to raise the city's minimum wage in 2016.

The appeals court ruled that one of the lawsuit's complaints -- that Alabama lawmakers discriminated against the city's black citizens and violated their equal protection rights under the 14th Amendment -- can proceed. The court dismissed other claims in the lawsuit.

In its decision, the three-judge panel said the legislative process that abolished the minimum wage increase was "rushed, reactionary and racially polarized." It also rejected what it described as a lower court's claim that only the "clearest proof" of discrimination would justify a court overriding a legislature's intent.

"Requiring the 'clearest proof' of discriminatory purpose not only ignores the history of equal protection law but also turns a blind eye to the realities of modern discrimination," the decision read. "Today, racism is no longer pledged from the portico of the capitol or exclaimed from the floor of the constitutional convention; it hides, abashed, cloaked beneath ostensibly neutral laws and legitimate bases, steering government power toward no less invidious ends."

Scott Douglas, executive director of Greater Birmingham Ministries and one of the plaintiffs in the suit, said he was surprised by some of the language in the court's decision.

"I told someone whoever wrote the decision must have read a lot of William Faulkner, who said in the South we don't put history behind us -- history isn't even in the past."

Mike Lewis, a spokesman for Alabama's Attorney General's office, said the state was still reviewing the decision and had no comment.

Invoking Alabama's racist past

The decision is the latest move in a national battle over the minimum wage. At least 21 states and the District of Columbia have raised their minimum wages above the federal level of $7.25 an hour, and more than 40 localities have adopted wages above their state minimums. Many have done so in response to protests by Fight for $15, a workers' movement that seeks to raise the minimum wage nationwide.

Legislatures in at least 25 states, including Alabama, have responded to the local minimum wage hikes by passing "pre-emption bills" that either abolish or roll back local increases. Wednesday's court victory for the movement is even more significant because it takes place in the South, which has traditionally been more hostile to workers' rights than other regions.

Mary Joyce Carlson, an attorney for the Fight for $15 campaign, noted that Birmingham is also the site of one of the civil rights movement's greatest victories. She said she was encouraged by some of the language in the decision, which talked about the realities of modern discrimination.

"The judges on this case are wise to the contemporary world," she said. "It's very reassuring to know that there are judges on the bench who are this perceptive."

Birmingham became the first city in the South to raise the minimum wage for anyone employed in its city limits, voting in February 2016 to set the wage at $10.10. The primary beneficiaries would have been fast-food and retail workers.

Alabama lawmakers responded by passing a law that abolished the wage increase. They said a minimum wage increase would cause job losses and that their decision had nothing to do with race.

The appeals court's decision, however, questioned that assertion:

"The Act was introduced by a white representative from Alabama's least diverse area, with the help of fifty-two other white sponsors, and was objected to by all black members of the House and Senate. And it was accelerated through the legislative process in sixteen days with little or no opportunity for public comment or debate. These facts plausibly imply discriminatory motivations were at play."

The appeals court decision is only a partial victory but Douglas, the activist, said he will take any kind of victory for workers in a political climate dominated by President Trump.

"It's a ray of light that breaks through the fog of Trumpism," Douglas said. "Some people say. 'Don't get too excited about one ray of light.' but I say let's expand it."

Huntsville
Overcast
66° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 63°
Feels Like: 66°
Florence
Scattered Clouds
66° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 62°
Feels Like: 66°
Fayetteville
Overcast
64° wxIcon
Hi: 80° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 64°
Decatur
Broken Clouds
65° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 62°
Feels Like: 65°
Scottsboro
Overcast
66° wxIcon
Hi: 80° Lo: 62°
Feels Like: 66°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 16530

Reported Deaths: 591
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Mobile2124112
Jefferson1712100
Montgomery154134
Tuscaloosa67813
Marshall6689
Lee53332
Franklin5147
Shelby48419
Tallapoosa41864
Butler39213
Chambers34924
Madison3184
Elmore3137
Walker2991
Baldwin2819
Etowah24411
Dallas2443
DeKalb2413
Morgan2311
Coffee2241
Lowndes22210
Sumter2136
Autauga2053
Houston1884
Bullock1833
Pike1790
Colbert1612
Russell1590
Marengo1556
Lauderdale1532
Calhoun1523
Hale1517
Choctaw1488
Wilcox1347
Barbour1321
Clarke1292
Randolph1257
Marion11911
St. Clair1161
Pickens1014
Talladega1003
Dale990
Chilton971
Cullman960
Greene924
Limestone870
Winston820
Covington771
Jackson752
Crenshaw722
Bibb711
Henry712
Macon712
Washington666
Blount581
Escambia493
Lawrence460
Geneva400
Conecuh351
Coosa351
Monroe352
Perry350
Cherokee342
Clay272
Lamar210
Fayette130
Cleburne131
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 21679

Reported Deaths: 356
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Davidson489460
Shelby4718107
Trousdale13934
Rutherford111622
Sumner85245
Hamilton71915
Bledsoe6081
Williamson53310
Putnam4615
Robertson4412
Tipton4303
Lake4130
Wilson3878
Out of TN3794
Knox3575
Bedford2744
Montgomery2613
Rhea1980
Hardeman1940
Madison1752
Loudon1370
McMinn13614
Macon1243
Cheatham1180
Cumberland1111
Dickson1100
Fayette1102
Bradley1081
Blount893
Maury810
Sevier762
Washington750
Coffee680
Unassigned670
Wayne630
Gibson611
Monroe612
Sullivan602
Hickman570
Lauderdale561
Dyer500
Franklin491
Greene482
Anderson391
Marion381
DeKalb370
Grundy321
Hawkins312
Haywood302
Smith301
Hamblen302
Henry300
Marshall301
White300
Obion281
Jefferson280
Carroll271
Meigs260
Overton260
Weakley260
Lincoln250
Lawrence240
Warren220
Cocke200
Carter191
Jackson170
Morgan170
Cannon170
Campbell171
Roane160
Crockett162
Perry160
Johnson160
Polk150
Sequatchie150
Henderson140
Humphreys131
Chester120
Fentress120
Giles120
McNairy120
Scott110
Stewart110
Hardin112
Claiborne90
Houston80
Benton71
Grainger60
Clay60
Decatur50
Van Buren40
Union40
Unicoi40
Moore30
Pickett30
Lewis30
Hancock10

 

 

Community Events