STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

The biggest political story no one is talking about

On Wednesday, two more Republicans ...

Posted: May 18, 2018 10:25 AM
Updated: May 18, 2018 10:25 AM

On Wednesday, two more Republicans signed on to a petition that would force an open-ended and unpredictable immigration debate onto the House floor -- a nightmare scenario that the White House and GOP leaders seem, at least at the moment, unable to stop.

The decisions by Republican Reps. John Katko of New York and Dave Trott of Michigan to sign on to the petition came in the wake of private urgings from House Speaker Paul Ryan to his GOP colleagues not to add their names to the list. The duo's act of defiance brought the number of Republicans signed onto the effort to 20, just five short of the number they need to force votes on four competing measures aimed at preserving the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. (That math -- 25 Republicans -- is dependent on all 193 Democrats supporting the effort.)

At the heart of the debate is the long-standing division within the GOP conference over what to do on immigration reform -- and the popular DACA program in particular -- amid swirling political winds.

On one end of the debate stand Trump, Ryan and the rest of the House Republican leaders who view a wide-open floor debate -- and a series of roll-call votes -- as a potentially disastrous visual for the party and one without any likely positive result. Ryan called such efforts "futile" on Thursday.

Trump, who ran hard on the need to toughen US immigration policy by, among other things, building a wall on the southern border, has little interest in some sort of compromise immigration legislation crafted by two dozen Republicans and congressional Democrats. He has said in recent days that he will push for full funding of his border wall in the next budget negotiation and has even floated the possibility he would be willing to shut down the federal government if his demands are not met.

On the other side you have a group of moderate Republicans and those in either swing seats or seats with large Hispanic populations. California Republican Rep. Jeff Denham is leading the charge on the petition effort; he represents a seat in which the population is nearly 50% Hispanic. The Republican rebels are driven by electoral worries and frustration, having spent years being told by their leaders to bide their time and they would, eventually, get the immigration debate they have been pushing for.

This is far from the first time that fissures within the Republican party over immigration have been on public display.

In the summer of 2007, President George W. Bush pushed hard on a comprehensive immigration reform effort. Arizona Sen. John McCain, at the time a leading candidate for the GOP presidential nomination, also put his full political force behind it. His primary opponents -- led by former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney -- painted McCain as soft on immigration and GOP primary voters rapidly soured on the Arizona Senator. The bill failed a procedural vote in June of that year, and McCain walked away from any further attempts at reform as he sought (and eventually won) the GOP nod.

In 2013, following a crushing defeat in the 2012 presidential race in which GOP nominee Romney won only 27% of Hispanic voters nationwide, a handful of Senate Republicans -- including McCain and 2016 presidential aspirant Marco Rubio of Florida -- led the charge, again, for comprehensive immigration reform. The bill passed the Senate by a remarkable 68-32 vote in June 2013. The House, run by more conservative Republicans who viewed the Senate bill as making far too many concessions to undocumented immigrants, refused to take up the legislation at all.

The midterm election victories for Republicans in 2014 seemed to prove that engaging on any sort of compromise deal on immigration was totally unnecessary and, in fact, was anathema to the desires of the party's base.

That belief was solidified by the rise of Trump in late 2015 and early 2016. Trump's candidacy was fueled by his insistence that immigration policies needed to be hardened and that the Republican party had let down its voters by not pushing more aggressively for tighter border security in recent years.

Which brings us, roughly, to today. Denham and other leaders in the petition movement have privately expressed confidence that they have the 25 GOP votes they need to force the leadership's hand. Democrats, who had held off signing the petition to make clear this wasn't a purely partisan effort, are likely to begin signing as soon as today.

At the moment, there appears to be a total of zero good options for Ryan and the rest of the GOP leaders to slide their way out of this. Give in to Denham's crowd and the immigration hardliners within the GOP conference -- of which there are many -- could well rebel in droves. Keep fighting the petition and run the risk of being cast as decidedly weak if and when the 25th Republican signs on to it.

Ryan is boxed in. His only option is to find an alternative piece of legislation that can satisfy the demands of Denham and avoid this showdown. But, if such a plan was readily available, Ryan would have already turned to it. That he hasn't suggests he may out of useable, much less good, options.

Huntsville
Clear
57° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 57°
Florence
Clear
58° wxIcon
Hi: 77° Lo: 54°
Feels Like: 58°
Fayetteville
Clear
55° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 49°
Feels Like: 55°
Decatur
Clear
57° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 57°
Scottsboro
Broken Clouds
59° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 59°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 128818

Reported Deaths: 2284
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson19015337
Mobile13066289
Montgomery8674173
Madison758375
Tuscaloosa7240114
Lee571359
Shelby568450
Baldwin506149
Marshall383543
Etowah335547
Calhoun333839
Morgan319726
Houston270822
Elmore254947
DeKalb235519
St. Clair223435
Walker222680
Talladega206926
Limestone199519
Cullman184517
Dallas174826
Franklin174328
Russell17132
Autauga169024
Lauderdale164633
Colbert160626
Escambia156225
Blount155114
Jackson150611
Chilton148527
Dale133043
Covington130927
Coffee12778
Pike11559
Tallapoosa113683
Chambers113042
Clarke104917
Marion94228
Butler90938
Barbour8357
Winston70912
Marengo69919
Lowndes64827
Pickens63514
Bibb63210
Hale61528
Randolph60812
Bullock58714
Lawrence58520
Monroe5758
Geneva5724
Cherokee56516
Washington54613
Clay5427
Perry5376
Wilcox53111
Conecuh52311
Crenshaw52331
Macon47720
Henry4724
Fayette4219
Sumter41819
Lamar3462
Choctaw34512
Cleburne3236
Greene30015
Coosa1643
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 183514

Reported Deaths: 2218
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby30062447
Davidson25972289
Hamilton910688
Rutherford898687
Knox892372
Williamson507736
Sumner468693
Wilson335841
Putnam306137
Montgomery295243
Out of TN294423
Unassigned28816
Bradley285016
Madison264156
Sevier251513
Blount243323
Maury223823
Washington216732
Robertson216233
Sullivan205131
Hamblen183625
Tipton173317
Trousdale16517
Hardeman152925
Gibson152319
Wayne14795
Bedford130516
Dyer126612
Dickson119312
Cumberland115217
Fayette113918
Carter112427
Henderson112419
Anderson112311
Weakley111719
Loudon11126
Greene110637
Coffee109712
Obion10889
Jefferson106614
McMinn106324
Macon101519
Warren10077
Monroe99516
Hardin96714
Lawrence95411
Lauderdale93715
Haywood91816
Franklin9067
Lake8732
Bledsoe8464
Roane8354
Carroll82917
McNairy80716
Cheatham78810
White7769
Rhea77211
Hawkins76616
Cocke7329
Marshall7135
Overton6784
Smith67310
Johnson6452
Henry6019
Chester5859
Lincoln5781
Giles56017
DeKalb54411
Hickman5304
Crockett50919
Marion4997
Decatur4706
Fentress4323
Claiborne4254
Campbell4163
Polk37711
Grainger3492
Union3341
Benton3329
Jackson3054
Morgan3043
Unicoi2771
Cannon2750
Grundy2465
Humphreys2273
Sequatchie2223
Meigs2203
Scott2002
Clay1875
Houston1850
Lewis1771
Stewart1732
Moore1531
Van Buren1530
Perry1430
Hancock1073
Pickett962

Community Events