Congress could kill safeguard against auto lending discrimination

Congress is considering killing an Obama-era rule that protects Americans from discriminatory car loans.The Se...

Posted: Apr 17, 2018 8:02 PM
Updated: Apr 17, 2018 8:02 PM

Congress is considering killing an Obama-era rule that protects Americans from discriminatory car loans.

The Senate could vote as soon as Tuesday to repeal auto lending regulations aimed at ensuring that minority car buyers aren't charged higher interest rates.

Critics of the 2013 rule argue that the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau overstepped its authority, hurting both the auto industry and car buyers.

"Republicans are chopping away at the tangled mess of regulations that the last administration left behind," Republican Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said on Tuesday.

McConnell said that overturning the rule would "protect consumers" and halt a "brazen attempt" by the CFPB to "interfere in the auto industry." He noted that Dodd-Frank, the post-financial crisis law that created the CFPB, prohibited the consumer watchdog agency from regulating auto dealers.

Yet there is little evidence that the auto industry is being strangled by regulation, and the industry has some history of discriminatory lending.

As recently as 2015, the Justice Department and the CFPB accused Ally Financial of charging higher interest rates to 235,000 car loan borrowers who were Hispanic, African-American or Asian/Pacific Islander.

Minority customers paid an additional $200 to $300 each over the life of the car loan, regulators said. Ally Financial, which paid $98 million to settle the case, said it doesn't believe its dealer network was deliberately discriminating.

"Auto dealers are actively discriminating against people of color," Karl Frisch, executive director of progressive consumer group Allied Progress, said in a statement.

"Unfortunately, the auto industry is in the driver's seat in the Senate and people of color are the ones being taken for a ride," Frisch said.

Related: Congress could give bank shareholders $53 billion gift

Auto dealers have great sway in Congress. Republican Senator Jerry Moran of Kansas, who introduced the repeal resolution, has received more than $225,000 in campaign contributions from the auto industry during his career in Congress, according to OpenSecrets.org. Moran's office declined to comment.

The controversy began in 2013. Instead of proposing a formal rule, the CFPB issued "guidance" warning auto lenders to adhere to fair-lending laws that prohibit discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, gender, age and other classes. The CFPB threatened to use "all appropriate regulatory tools" to ensure that auto lending is fair.

The Government Accountability Office ruled last year that the CFPB guidance is effectively a rule. That makes it subject to the Congressional Review Act, which allows lawmakers to repeal regulations they disapprove of with a simple majority.

Overturning the rule would still require approval by the House and President Trump.

An editorial in The Wall Street Journal this month slammed the auto lending regulation as "one of Obama's worst rules" and applauded GOP efforts to repeal it. "Relief may finally be on the way," the paper said.

Related: Trump official denies he's trying to destroy CFPB

Yet there is evidence that minorities have been charged more for car loans.

The National Consumer Law Center found "widespread racial disparities, unrelated to credit risks" in the pricing of car loans between the late 1990s and the early 2000s nationwide.

The nonprofit consumer group said significant racial disparities were found in "every state with sufficient data and in every region of the country." In some states, black borrowers were charged 300% more for car loans than white borrowers.

"Let's be clear. Discrimination in auto lending is alive and well," Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren said on Tuesday from the Senate floor. She called a vote in favor of the resolution a "vote to support the Trump administration's systematic dismantling of fair lending laws in this country."

The CFPB declined to comment on efforts to gut the auto lending rule. Mick Mulvaney, who was appointed acting director by Trump, has moved to rein in the consumer watchdog agency. As a congressman, he pushed to abolish it.

The Consumer Federation of America, a nonprofit group, warned that repealing the auto lending guidance "would grant car dealers free rein to discriminate against minority borrowers."

Despite the greater scrutiny from regulators, the auto industry is thriving, and access to credit appears strong. Car sales dipped slightly last year, but remain near record highs. Auto loans hit an all-time high last year, according to the New York Federal Reserve.

Americans have increased their auto debt by $427 billion, or 54%, since the CFPB guidance was issued in early 2013, according to NY Fed data.

Auto loan debt stood at an all-time high of $1.2 trillion at the end of 2017. In fact, last year Americans added a record amount of auto debt.

- CNN's Donna Borak and Ted Barrett contributed to this report.

Huntsville
Scattered Clouds
89° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 68°
Feels Like: 90°
Florence
Clear
88° wxIcon
Hi: 92° Lo: 69°
Feels Like: 93°
Fayetteville
Clear
88° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 96°
Decatur
Broken Clouds
86° wxIcon
Hi: 88° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 92°
Scottsboro
Clear
90° wxIcon
Hi: 87° Lo: 69°
Feels Like: 95°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 56441

Reported Deaths: 1136
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson7012170
Mobile5061140
Montgomery4599112
Tuscaloosa274353
Madison25359
Marshall205012
Shelby176425
Lee164737
Morgan13975
Baldwin134111
Walker111332
Elmore107622
Etowah106914
Dallas10189
DeKalb10017
Franklin95016
Unassigned77728
Autauga71515
Russell7130
Chambers68530
Cullman6686
Limestone6653
Butler65529
Houston6417
Tallapoosa63069
Lauderdale6006
St. Clair5983
Calhoun5545
Colbert5286
Escambia5128
Lowndes49222
Pike4805
Jackson4422
Coffee4364
Covington43512
Talladega4177
Dale4061
Barbour4022
Bullock37810
Hale36323
Marengo36111
Chilton3452
Blount3311
Clarke3236
Wilcox3158
Marion30914
Winston3095
Sumter29713
Pickens2786
Randolph2759
Monroe2683
Perry2552
Conecuh2388
Bibb2271
Macon2229
Choctaw22012
Greene2009
Henry1573
Washington1529
Lawrence1460
Crenshaw1343
Cherokee1317
Geneva1010
Fayette901
Clay892
Lamar891
Coosa671
Cleburne481
Out of AL00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 65274

Reported Deaths: 749
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby14163224
Davidson13976146
Rutherford375539
Hamilton353538
Sumner204056
Williamson193916
Knox171710
Out of TN166012
Trousdale15105
Wilson126117
Putnam10817
Unassigned10772
Bradley10104
Robertson97313
Sevier9244
Montgomery8247
Tipton7177
Lake6960
Macon6467
Bledsoe6311
Bedford6309
Hamblen5084
Maury4993
Hardeman4444
Madison3842
Fayette3805
Rhea3500
Blount3483
Loudon3312
Dyer3023
McMinn29319
Cheatham2873
Dickson2820
Washington2760
Lawrence2506
Sullivan2485
Cumberland2294
Anderson2112
Gibson2031
Jefferson1931
Lauderdale1934
Smith1852
Warren1590
Greene1572
Monroe1566
Coffee1520
Cocke1460
Haywood1413
Hardin1407
Obion1273
Marshall1232
Wayne1230
Franklin1223
Giles1221
McNairy1171
Hickman1120
Carter1082
Marion1014
DeKalb990
Hawkins952
Lincoln950
White933
Roane880
Henderson830
Chester810
Overton791
Weakley791
Claiborne760
Campbell721
Grundy672
Crockett653
Unicoi600
Grainger590
Cannon580
Carroll571
Polk570
Henry540
Sequatchie520
Jackson500
Johnson490
Humphreys482
Perry430
Meigs400
Decatur350
Morgan341
Fentress290
Scott290
Union280
Stewart270
Clay230
Houston230
Moore230
Benton161
Hancock120
Lewis120
Van Buren90
Pickett80

 

 

Community Events