The case for Donald Trump's mental fitness

In the wake of three days of erratic behavior and amid the controversy caused by a book suggesting he is forgetful an...

Posted: Jan 5, 2018 9:50 AM
Updated: Jan 5, 2018 9:50 AM

In the wake of three days of erratic behavior and amid the controversy caused by a book suggesting he is forgetful and dismissed by many who work for him, questions of President Donald Trump's mental competence are everywhere.

At Thursday's press briefing, White House press secretary Sarah Sanders called the idea that Trump was mentally unfit for the job "disgraceful and laughable." She added: "If he was unfit, he probably wouldn't be sitting there, wouldn't have defeated the most qualified group of candidates the Republican Party has ever seen."

While it's far from a determinative explanation from Sanders, she does have a point. And the point is this: Trump is who he has always been.

Think about the sorts of behaviors that Trump's critics point to as examples of his lack of mental competence or deteriorating mental state:

  • He is impetuous
  • He is quick to anger
  • He appears unengaged in details
  • He keeps erratic hours
  • He says things that are provably false
  • He has an exaggerated -- and grandiose -- vision of his own life
  • He punishes enemies

There are others, of course. But these, I think, broadly cover the competence critique made against Trump.

Now, go back over that list. And ask yourself whether any of those behaviors are new since Trump has been elected president.

While you're doing that, let me remind you that Trump did the following things as either a candidate or private citizen:

Impersonated a young publicist within the Trump Organization to leak flattering details about his own personal life to the New York tabloids. Spent several years pursuing the totally debunked idea that President Barack Obama wasn't born in the United States Made a series of lewd comments about women caught on tape by "Access Hollywood" (and then argued the tape might be a fake) Insisted that 3-5 million votes were cast illegally in the 2016 election Suggested Ted Cruz's father might have been involved in the assassination of John Kennedy

Those are the ones I came up with off the top of my head. There are scores of others examples just like them.

There is a clear pattern of behavior there that long predates Trump's time in the White House or even his decision to run for president. Trump is today who he has been the entirety of his adult life.

That is a person that many Americans find to be loathsome. Or incompetent. Or mentally unwell.

He is also the person who 62,984,825 people, or 46.09% of US voters in 2016, supported -- and those people happened to live in just the right states for Trump to win the electoral college even while losing the popular vote by a historic margin.

Given his prominence in the culture and the incredibly high profile of the 2016 presidential race, it's very tough for me to believe that the people who voted for Trump did so without knowing who he really was. The Trump on the campaign trail -- full of bravado, fiercely unapologetic, dramatic, obsessed with victimization -- was the Trump of the wheeling-and-dealing 1980s. It was the Trump of the reality TV show years. And it is the Trump of the White House.

The obvious pushback to this argument is that simply because Trump's behavior isn't inconsistent with who he has been his entire life doesn't mean that he is mentally well enough to hold the office of the presidency.

Fair enough. I am not a psychologist or a psychiatrist, so diagnosing what, if anything, has long been wrong with Trump mentally (and if that impedes his ability to do the job) is well beyond my skill set.

But what seems clear -- at least to me -- is that the case for some sort of mental deterioration from Trump since he has been in office simply isn't there.

Is it possible Trump has sunk more into his ways and habits (and insecurities) as he continues to age? Sure -- since lots and lots of people do exactly that as they get older.

However, he appears to be acting as President how he has always acted. And that is who got elected President -- like it or, more likely, hate it.

Huntsville
Clear
47° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 38°
Feels Like: 47°
Florence
Scattered Clouds
47° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 45°
Fayetteville
Clear
50° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 37°
Feels Like: 50°
Decatur
Scattered Clouds
45° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 36°
Feels Like: 45°
Scottsboro
Clear
54° wxIcon
Hi: 65° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 54°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 239318

Reported Deaths: 3532
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson31391491
Mobile19562361
Tuscaloosa12813154
Madison12741146
Montgomery12198235
Shelby1000577
Baldwin847398
Lee764466
Morgan634348
Calhoun6112115
Marshall607954
Etowah606565
Houston517038
DeKalb474736
Cullman428038
Limestone413744
St. Clair409055
Elmore400762
Lauderdale393653
Walker3588108
Talladega343453
Jackson307624
Colbert301941
Blount285539
Autauga268641
Franklin247833
Coffee239715
Dale230354
Dallas224531
Russell22053
Chilton219638
Covington216833
Escambia197431
Chambers173749
Tallapoosa173391
Pike157514
Clarke156319
Marion136535
Winston129923
Lawrence124836
Geneva12028
Pickens119418
Marengo119124
Barbour117010
Bibb116217
Butler114441
Randolph100921
Cherokee100824
Hale94531
Clay90223
Washington90219
Fayette87316
Henry8496
Lowndes79129
Monroe78111
Cleburne75714
Macon72321
Crenshaw70730
Bullock69119
Conecuh68314
Perry6756
Lamar6508
Wilcox63118
Sumter57122
Choctaw41913
Greene41418
Coosa3374
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 347972

Reported Deaths: 4466
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby46176651
Davidson40984412
Knox17878142
Rutherford17025154
Hamilton16137149
Williamson1077979
Sumner9248135
Wilson708477
Out of TN680251
Montgomery627183
Sullivan618896
Putnam575282
Washington5667102
Maury560266
Blount525859
Madison5164108
Bradley493235
Sevier471231
Unassigned433722
Robertson360451
Tipton353738
Hamblen336059
Dyer312350
Gibson308365
Greene290371
Anderson276528
Dickson276333
Coffee268141
Bedford259530
Carter259355
Obion255449
Lawrence253533
Cumberland245335
McMinn235855
Warren227818
Roane223828
Hardeman221837
Loudon220718
Jefferson219032
Fayette216038
Weakley209636
Monroe203944
Lauderdale200722
Franklin196133
Trousdale190012
Hawkins184734
Wayne181610
Henderson179433
Macon177728
Hardin173425
White168618
Marshall166720
Carroll165534
Haywood160030
Rhea158330
Cocke156130
Overton151235
Cheatham150816
Campbell150023
Lincoln149414
Henry146317
Johnson139621
Smith139419
Giles138546
McNairy138133
Fentress118120
Lake11545
Bledsoe11445
Hickman113018
Crockett112226
DeKalb109922
Marion105419
Chester100020
Scott9967
Grainger93915
Decatur92413
Unicoi81026
Claiborne7779
Benton77215
Grundy74914
Lewis72714
Cannon7183
Union7005
Morgan6886
Jackson66910
Humphreys6687
Polk64115
Houston57920
Stewart57214
Clay53318
Sequatchie5025
Perry46521
Meigs46012
Moore3773
Pickett37613
Van Buren3462
Hancock1503

Community Events