STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Admin can't block undocumented pregnant teens in US custody from seeking abortions, judge says

A federal judge ruled Monday that the Trump administration could not obstruct two undocumented pregnant teens in US c...

Posted: Dec 19, 2017 12:27 PM
Updated: Dec 19, 2017 12:27 PM

A federal judge ruled Monday that the Trump administration could not obstruct two undocumented pregnant teens in US custody from seeking abortions.

In her order, US District Judge Tanya S. Chutkan required the administration to allow the two teens to be transported to an abortion provider "in order to obtain any pregnancy related or abortion-related medical care and to obtain the abortion procedure itself."

Chutkan held that the teens would suffer "irreparable injury" without the order and said that she issued it in view of the need to preserve the girls' "constitutional right to decide whether to carry their pregnancies to term."

The judge did agree to stay her ruling for 24 hours pending appeal.

The Department of Justice said it would appeal the ruling.

At issue are two teens, known in court papers as "Jane Poe and Jane Roe." They are both pregnant undocumented 17 year-olds, being held in US custody in two different, undisclosed states.

The ACLU, representing the teens, sought a temporary restraining order from the court to prohibit the federal government from blocking the teens' access to abortion.

"Absent an immediate temporary restraining order, Ms. Roe and Ms. Poe will both be pushed further into their pregnancies, increasing the risks associated with the abortion procedure, and if, the Court does not intervene, Ms. Roe and Ms. Poe will be forced to carry to term against their will," Brigitte Amiri, an ACLU lawyer, argued in court papers.

Separate from the request for emergency relief, the ACLU is also seeking class certification and a permanent injunction against what it says is the Trump administration's new policy from March prohibiting all federally funded shelters from taking any action to facilitate abortion access for unaccompanied minors. That request is still pending.

Roe is about 10 weeks pregnant, according to the ACLU. The government contends that it is working on finding her a sponsor and that the process is "near completion."

According to the government, Poe is nearly 22 weeks pregnant, and as recently as December 4, she told officials she wanted to continue with the pregnancy. The ACLU disputes the government's assertion and argued that Poe is "quickly approaching the point at which abortion will no longer be an option. "

August E. Flentje, the administration lawyer, said in court briefs that the government has "strong and constitutionally legitimate interests in promoting its interest in life, in refusing to facilitate abortion and in not providing incentives for pregnant minors to illegally cross the border to obtain elective abortions while in federal custody. "

The parties argued a similar case before her last month concerning a teen being held in Texas who is called "Jane Doe" in court papers. Chutkan ruled in favor of Doe and the teen also prevailed in a federal appeals court. After that ruling, Doe obtained an abortion. But the Solicitor General later filed papers with the Supreme Court asking the justices to vacate that opinion and arguing that it was not aware the procedure was to go forward before it could file an appeal. That case is still before the justices.

In a statement, Amiri, a senior staff attorney with the ACLU's Reproductive Freedom Project, called the judge's decision Monday "a reminder that both the law and justice are on our side" and cited the Texas case.

"Unfortunately, the Trump administration has shown no indication that they'll abandon their cruel and dystopian crusade to block abortion access for some of the most marginalized people in our country," Amiri said. "We're prepared to keep fighting for as long as we need to."

In Court on Monday, Flentje distinguished the most recent case from the "Doe" case, noting that while Doe lived in a state that required a judicial waiver before the minor could obtain an abortion, the states involved in the latest case do not require such a waiver."

Huntsville
Clear
70° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 70°
Florence
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 79° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 72°
Fayetteville
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 68°
Decatur
Clear
66° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 58°
Feels Like: 66°
Scottsboro
Broken Clouds
66° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 66°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 17061

Reported Deaths: 611
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Mobile2162114
Jefferson1744102
Montgomery159038
Tuscaloosa72014
Marshall6819
Franklin5407
Lee53632
Shelby49719
Tallapoosa42264
Butler39616
Chambers35224
Walker3302
Madison3244
Elmore3237
Baldwin2829
Dallas2553
Etowah24711
Morgan2441
DeKalb2433
Lowndes22711
Coffee2261
Sumter2166
Autauga2123
Houston2044
Bullock2014
Pike1910
Colbert1652
Russell1620
Marengo1606
Hale1578
Lauderdale1562
Calhoun1533
Choctaw1498
Barbour1471
Wilcox1417
Clarke1342
Randolph1257
Marion12011
St. Clair1181
Cullman1140
Pickens1094
Dale1060
Talladega1063
Chilton991
Greene934
Limestone920
Winston870
Covington771
Jackson762
Crenshaw733
Henry732
Macon723
Bibb711
Washington676
Blount601
Escambia573
Lawrence480
Geneva390
Coosa381
Conecuh381
Cherokee363
Monroe362
Perry350
Clay272
Lamar230
Cleburne141
Fayette130
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 22063

Reported Deaths: 361
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Davidson496860
Shelby4823110
Trousdale13934
Rutherford116222
Sumner85845
Hamilton75315
Bledsoe6081
Williamson54210
Putnam4656
Robertson4493
Tipton4373
Lake4130
Wilson3898
Out of TN3794
Knox3665
Bedford2834
Montgomery2623
Rhea2090
Hardeman1950
Madison1752
Loudon1420
McMinn13614
Macon1303
Cheatham1180
Bradley1131
Fayette1122
Cumberland1111
Dickson1100
Blount893
Maury880
Sevier802
Washington750
Coffee700
Unassigned670
Wayne630
Gibson621
Monroe612
Sullivan602
Hickman570
Lauderdale561
Franklin511
Dyer500
Greene492
Marion391
Anderson391
DeKalb370
Hamblen342
Smith321
Hawkins322
Grundy321
White310
Marshall311
Haywood302
Henry300
Obion301
Lawrence290
Jefferson280
Carroll271
Overton260
Meigs260
Weakley260
Lincoln250
Warren230
Cocke200
Carter191
Perry170
Morgan170
Cannon170
Jackson170
Campbell171
Roane160
Johnson160
Crockett162
Sequatchie150
Henderson150
Polk150
Humphreys131
Chester120
Fentress120
McNairy120
Scott120
Giles120
Hardin122
Stewart110
Claiborne90
Houston80
Benton71
Clay70
Grainger60
Decatur50
Van Buren40
Union40
Unicoi40
Pickett30
Lewis30
Moore30
Hancock10

 

 

Community Events